The last box that we opened we couldn't open the lids without breaking the container open. Big mess. After getting open the foil seal was still closed. What a pain.

Taste isn't good. I thought I'd try these since I couldn't find Fairlife, and they are NOT the same. Super thick and weak chocolate flavor. Not a good sub for FL.

I’ve been drinking a name brand chocolate protein shake each morning and tried the Member’s Mark Brand which is great, less expensive and helps my budget. Great find!

This is a fairly decent protein shake! Did not have a chalky after taste that is often the case with chocolate. It reminded me more of a chocolate milk. It is really good as a frozen drink blended with ice. The sodium is actually pretty good too- 180mg is fairly low for a protein drink . Will buy again!

I’ve been trying to get more protein in my diet and these protein shakes have been an easy way to do it. They are high in protein at 30 grams, fairly low calorie and low on added sugar. They taste much better cold in my opinion so I always chill them first. I’m not a huge fan of protein drinks but these are ok. Not great tasting but not horrible either. My husband drinks them every morning and likes the taste, so it’s personal preference.

Number one thing on this is the flavor was pretty darn good for being a protein shake. It’s very chocolaty. Consistency was also very smooth. I do like the packaging and the convenience of them. Easy to pack and take with you if you need too. The reason i gave 4 stars was because of some of the ingredients, i cant even pronounce some of these.

I bought this the other day because the Fairlife shakes I have bought for many years was no longer there. I thought I'd give this a try. It is chalky, has a terrible aftertaste, and smells like tube feeding formula. Absolutely disgusting. Sams - please bring back Fairlife. There is literally no substitute for Fairlife. The only place this member mark shake belongs is in the trash. Don't waste your money on it!

I usually get the Fairlife protein drinks, which are also chocolate and have 30g of protein. The main problem is that they seem to be out of stock all the time. I read reviews and decided to give these a chance based on the positive reviews. I think the positive reviewers must be used to something really terrible because these are not good. They're way too sweet and have a metallic flavor worse than slim fast. It's like someone ground up an old car and mixed the dust with some milk and chocolate syrup. If you like that metallic overly sweet flavor, buy these, otherwise you'll want to pass.

I hadn't noticed these MM chocolate protein shakes before at Sam's Club, until just recently and from what some reviewers have said, after they went from 18 to 15 per box and thinner consistency than they used to be. I've been mainly drinking another regional store brand for a few years. Agreed the consistency of these is on the thinner side but I mostly like them for the protein, and I'm very happy with the price. I'll review the ingredients including preservatives against the shakes I've been drinking, but will probably continue drinking these for the price. We'll see how my 90-year-old mother likes them. Fortunately she also takes a multivitamin every day.

Extremely disappointing new version of the Members Mark protein drink! There is no whey protein any longer. It lacks many of the minerals and vitamins in the previous version. Less iron and potassium. Aftertaste due to the Sucralose sweetener. It’s really too bad that you took out beneficial ingredients, in order to make more money. I would have expected you would sell a quality product and not cut corners on customers health.