Just switched from Premier Brand protein shake to Member's Mark. Premier changed their recipe to a sweet sludge, in my opinion. MM tastes good and has the nutrition I need. Only issue is the caps. Too often untwisting the cap does not remove the under foil. I hope they fix that. Also the nutrition facts do not include fiber content. Hope they fix that too.

Says it's flavored chocolate. They did remember to color it brown like chocolate , but forgot to add the flavor of chocolate. It may be cheaper than other brands, but drinking 11 ounces of a chalk-like substance is quite a chore. So sorry I ordered 2 cases first thing.

Just bought these for the first time. Disappointed! On my 4th bottle and none have opened easy. Have to put it in my mouth and twist to open. Then have to puncture the seal inside with something. I have also bought the Adkins and Boost. Have not had this problem with those. Taste is ok. Does leave my mouth and lips feeling kinda dry. Price was good, but if they all are gonna be hard to open, probably wont buy again.

I really wanted to love these shakes because of the price. I'm new to the Protein Shake world and so far have found that the few I tried tasted a little better with each sip and you kind of get used to it. Not this one. It was very hard to get down so I'll be donating them. It tasted too much like fake sugar and just gross in general.

If your go-to protein shake is Premier Protein Chocolate, you won't like the Member's Mark "equivalent." I tried them hoping to save a few dollars, but found them too sweet with a more pronounced artificial chocolate flavor. On the other hand, if you don't like Premier Protein, you might like these.

I am so disappointed Members Mark changed this. I have bought and used this product for a couple years. Members Mark recently changed the card board box that it was packed in. The product was also changed!! It now tastes like chocolate water. I will not buy it again. I am so disappointed.

I love the flavor and consistency and buy these regularly. I would give these 5 stars if it wasn't for the following issue that is becoming a dealbreaker for me: Approximately on average of one shake out of every1-2 cases will be defective and drip everywhere. The plastic sippy top separates slightly from the front of the container causing the liquid to spill out down the front of the container as you sip - and onto whatever you are wearing if you don't realize the one you're drinking has this defect. This just happened yet again and I'm getting fed up. We've consumed protein shakes for years, and this is the only brand that has caused this issue for us.

I bought this the other day because the Fairlife shakes I have bought for many years was no longer there. I thought I'd give this a try. It is chalky, has a terrible aftertaste, and smells like tube feeding formula. Absolutely disgusting. Sams - please bring back Fairlife. There is literally no substitute for Fairlife. The only place this member mark shake belongs is in the trash. Don't waste your money on it!

These are decent. They use to be better before they changed them. The red carton they use to be, was so easy to drink and I actually wanted to drink one a day. These ones are more chunky even after shaking them and drinking them fast. They just have a different taste and aren't something I WANT to drink.

Honestly one of the most artificially tasting protein shakes ever. Tried it because my club stopped bringing Fairlife protein shakes. Fairlife is my benchmark of great shakes and after the change, I would rank Member's Mark protein in the lower end of the spectrum.