While this product may be amazing in its ingredients, it was packaged much like my nondairy protein and placed right where I was use to picking up mine. In the long run it caused me to have mouth sores and stomach issues. I am grateful that I don’t have a serious, life threatening reaction to milk or this text would not have been written by me. 🫢😳

These were my favorite protein shake, so I didn't really mind having to buy a smaller pack because I thought they'd at least taste the same. Boy was I wrong. Somehow they have less flavor but more aftertaste, and it's pretty gross. I'll not be buying more of these unless they change them back.

This new, or replaced, Member's Mark protein shake took out thr good protein, i.e., took out the Milk Protein Isolate and Whey Protein Concentrate. The label now only shows protein concentrate. For a person who likes to work out this is a no-no. So now I have to find something else or start taking the extra time to mix my own shake from the good protein powder. Very disapointed, but who cares, right?

Bad taste

they're a great product, great price but the lid is almost always busted. I twist and 50% of the time the aluminum film isn't torn from inside the bottle. it's an incredibly common issue and the most frustrating thing to happen right before drinking one.

There is a huge, and disappointing, difference between the original protein shake and this one. I used to prefer this brand to Premier Protein but now will spend a little more for a palatable protein shake. This product was the main reason for maintaining my Sam's membership. Guess I won't need to do that anymore.

The new packaging comes with a new flavor profile for the chocolate. I drink one of these daily for the last year and a half. The ingredients have changed and so has the flavor. It's tastes fake and leaves an aftertaste. The old ones did not. There is no comparison. I know they compete with Premier, and this new rebrand doesn't cut it. New box, 15 shakes instead of 18, and bad flavor. Still a cost savings, but I'm not sure if it's worth it since I no longer enjoy it.

These are decent. They use to be better before they changed them. The red carton they use to be, was so easy to drink and I actually wanted to drink one a day. These ones are more chunky even after shaking them and drinking them fast. They just have a different taste and aren't something I WANT to drink.

I like the chocolate. To me it's taste just as good as the Ensure and they both have 30 grams of protein. Member's Mark does have a little less in the percentage amount of the vitamins than Ensure, but since I take a vitamin pill, I'm not that concerned. You also get a quantity of 15 for Member's Mark versus the 12 of Ensure and the Member's Mark price is much better.

Another Members Mark remake of a great product. Atkins Dark Chocolate are better tasting than MM Chocolate. Several other products that my family enjoyed eating that were available at Sams Club have now been discontinued and replaced by a lesser quality MM copy product. We no longer buy many products at SC because of this change to MM copy products. However, we are lucky enough to find our favorite named brand products at our local grocery store. Buying products in bulk does not overshadow the desire to have a quality and tasty product.