I have been using the Fairlife protein chocolate for quite sometime now. Thought I'd try these as they seemed to be the same as the Fairlife. Not so. They were disguisting (if you don't tolerate the sucralose very well). I even added frozen strawberries to cut the taste. Found out after the fact that they are non returnable...so waste of $$$ there. Just pay a bit more and get the better taste with Fairlife.

The new packaging comes with a new flavor profile for the chocolate. I drink one of these daily for the last year and a half. The ingredients have changed and so has the flavor. It's tastes fake and leaves an aftertaste. The old ones did not. There is no comparison. I know they compete with Premier, and this new rebrand doesn't cut it. New box, 15 shakes instead of 18, and bad flavor. Still a cost savings, but I'm not sure if it's worth it since I no longer enjoy it.

These were my favorite protein shake, so I didn't really mind having to buy a smaller pack because I thought they'd at least taste the same. Boy was I wrong. Somehow they have less flavor but more aftertaste, and it's pretty gross. I'll not be buying more of these unless they change them back.

I really didn't like it. Upon pouring the shake into a glass, I smelled a slight chemical odor. The taste was nondescript, but not really good. Definitely not chocolate. The chemical taste was mild, but present. And now, I have an aftertaste from the chemicals, I presume. I won't buy this again, and I will struggle to drink the remaining 14 in the case. There are much better tasting products on the market

I'm low on protein on my 90 day blood labs for my doctor, have been for years. Have taken one shake a day off and on in the past to no apparent avail. Doctor told me to take two a day which I am doing pretty faithfully at present and have about 7-8 weeks to go before another lab test. I'm 78 years old, pretty active, but don't feel much different. So I'll see what the next labs show in late September.

Had no choice than to move on from the original Red Member's Mark Protein Shake for this, poor performance, took the Whey out drop the number in carton from 18 to 15 made a trashy protein drink, when the original red was the best in the class. Less Iron, Less potassium which human body needs both. Whomever made the decision to change the formula should be fired!

I was disappointed that the previous MM protein shake product was no longer available. I put off purchasing this one because I felt Sam's was trying to make me buy a higher priced item. But because FailrLife is always out of stock, I started buying this product. My family loves it. And since it is a tad less cost than FairLife and basically the same, we will continue to buy it.

worst tasting protein drink I ever had. My normal brand has been out o stock for a few weeks now. While trying to match nutrient values up as close to possible I decided to try this. Sorry I did. Wish there was a money back guarantee so i could return it. Most likely will just toss it

I wanted to like this as they are cheaper than alternatives, but they just tasted watery and powdery. I'm comparing this to Fairlife which is real milk, and even the Member's Mark vanilla shakes are primarily real milk - for this one, you'll see the main ingredient is water. I'm looking for something I actually enjoy drinking, so I'll be going back to the Fairlife chocolate nutrition shakes.

Something happened to these protein shakes and it wasn't for the good. The last batch I've bought in recently in January is thick and slimy and the consistency is absolutely horrible. I don't know what they've done to this protein shake, but I used to drink them and they used to be great now they're so thick and slimy. I can't even drink them anymore.