These rawhide sticks are perfect for my 50lb boxer puppy. It's about an hour or two of chewing time for her. These are actually cheaper here at Sam's than they are at the dollar store. I have recommended these to friends and their dogs have loved them too.

I have 2 - 50lb dogs & they love these things!! My husband cuts them in half and gives them each a half. It's like a game & treat all wrapped into one. They both try to peel back the layers to get to the center. Once the center is out, they then start the chewing process. It's like a task with a reward. It makes the rawhides last longer. They really look forward to getting one of these so they can "figure out the puzzle". They eat these outside, too so there isn't any mess for me.

Our 110-pound aggressive chewer eats one of these almost daily. I worry about tummy issues, but the vet said that as long as he's not swallowing big chunks, he's fine. It takes him an average of 40 minutes to get through an entire hide, and it does leave a residue where he lays and on his front paws. But no loose stools or upset tummy from what we can tell. Great product at a reasonable price.

As other reviewers mentioned - the old brand of rawhide bones that Sam's used to carry were great, but these Canine Chews are not worth the money. My dog won't even chew on them anymore. :( She gets so excited, chews on it for a minute and then just walks away. We think they may be too hard for her. Waste of money.

My dogs go thru withdrawals when we run out of these rawhides. They are obsessed with these and I have had a hard time replacing them with another brand when Sam's Club doesn't keep them in stock. I have resorted to buying them in bulk when they are available because the availability is unpredictable.

I have two rescue dogs and the girls LOVE these!! They may not be the most healthy option, but the dogs are always monitored while they have these treats. My girls are 40 and 60 lbs. They take awhile to get thru them and are always excited to get them.

When my dog was teething, he would go through these in a few minutes, but now he takes a little more time with them. The bits that break off while they're dry are not really a problem, as he'll go back and vacuum them up himself when he finishes the main event. After he's slobbered on these for a few minutes, bits don't really break off anymore. Anything that may be left over is easy to suck up with a vacuum cleaner. I'd rather have him eating these than the old unbreakable rawhides that could clog up his digestive system. It would be nice if they were less expensive, but they are a quality product.

The only reason I bought this item on the internet was because I looked at three Sam's clubs for better than three weeks and none of the instore clubs stocked them, no room on the shelves for them, so I bought them on the internet. I have no opinion on them because they are for my dog. PS dogs have lots of the same name. Don't ever send my this junk again.

Repeat buyer! I have been getting these for my girl Teddy for years. She absolutely loves them. She is not treat motivated when I am trying to get her to come in the house but one wave of her ‘bone’ from up on the deck and she comes running. She is three years old, mix breed, according to embark mostly pittie so maybe that’s why she has a strong chew desire. I also got her from a rescue so I don’t know her history but these really calm her down, sort of like my evening cocktail! One will last her about a week. If your dog is smaller you might want to look at smaller ones.

My German Shepherd normally tears up any kind of chew treat he’s given. He didn’t care for these though. It’s such a large bag that it took several months for him to slowly go through them. He’s had similar ones before that he loved but he didn’t like these. Won’t be buying again.