Honestly I didn’t know what to expect from We have purchased countless “super chewer” toys that promised everything. These toys literally have our dogs chewing on it it forever! They are obsessed. These deliver what they promise and will outlast any super chewer, guaranteed.

My dog absolutely loves these. They are great for keeping him occupied however bits of the bones do come off. He is an intense chewer though. Unfortunately they do have a slight smell and then make my dogs breath HORRIBLE! But 4/5 stars because they are mostly durable and my dog loves them!

It's identical to the high end item I had been buying, and my dogs love them all!! They are English Bulldogs and can tear through anything. These are durable, not soft and rubbery but more like a hard plastic. They do not flake, or fall apart. 3rd day nonstop chewing and they still look like new! Buying 5 more packs! Hope Sam's doesn't stop carrying these! Buy them while you can!

We have a 20# Chiweenie and 50# cattle dog mix. We had 2 flavored Nylabones in the box—totally ignored. this set was a good price and i wondered if the bacon flavor would be more enticing. IT WAS. now the pile of bones in the bone box are gathering dust since all they want are these 3 bones.

I have spent a small fortune on elk antlers and other chew toys made for aggressive chewers only to have my puppy plow through them in a couple of hours. Not only does she favor the Lumabones over her other toys but she has had these for over a month and they are still holding up.

I have used similar wishbones/sticks from benebone since she was a puppy. Her old ones were getting worn and saw these at Sam's and thought I'd try these. They are a little heavy as some have mentioned, but my 30+ lb pup didn't seem to mind. I was most surprised by the "wag and roll". She was instantly engaged with the toy as soon as I put it on the floor. She played with it for a bit, then picked it up and carried it away to chew on. I'll be be buying another set of these to have as a backup.

Did not realize how large these were and bought them for an 8 lb Chihuahua. he did try to chew on them and play and could pick them up but just got them yesterday afternoon and he has thrown up twice this morning. This was the only thing he had new or different yesterday. I'm wondering if I should have washed them before giving them to him in case there was something on them from a warehouse or somewhere from shipping.

I followed the instructions and monitored my dogs while the chewed them. My one dog chewed a little bit, my other dog Tera REALLY got into it. I checked on her 10 minutes later to make sure she wasn’t biting chunks off, and found the end of the bone covered in blood. Can’t recommend a toy that gets that sharp that fast and causes physical damage. Had to throw them all away.

Love, love, love this! This is such a great value and it holds up to my heavy chewer puppy that is 40 lbs. I found this in store and I am so happy I found it and my dog loves it. This would also be a great gift for your pup or someone else’s. You could even break it up and give each one to a different dog.

My dogs love these -- all of them! They chew constantly - on the toys for once rather than on our furniture. GREAT for keeping their teeth clean too. They last a while, but our pups are heavy chewers, so maybe a month before we have to replace them. Wish Sams would get them back in stock - our supply is running low