So I’m trying to be watchful of my spending and dogs always have priority. Well these treats that they have had before because we only trust certain ingredients for dogs , anyway . They each get 2 once a day if I’m low on something twice a day . 3 dogs . My newest rescue is always cautious. Smells thoroughly, licks then can reject or go for it . First I got nothing then he saw other two eat them. That was it . He drools when I get box out. That’s 5 stars in my book. .

My boxer love's them!!!

Cookies were all broken. Outside box was fine. Opened it up tow two boxes that looked like the were tossed around. They were packed well so I suspect they were damaged before packaging.

Dogs did not like these at all. My dogs are not picky, they normally eat all treats. The young pup and the older dog both refuse these. They have had other Blue Buffalo treats that they loved.

These treat are hit or miss with our dogs. Main reason appear to be they are too hard to eat due shape and hardness. I would suggest for larger breeds.

First time I gave my dogs this treat they drop it on the ground and looked at me like what's this, where's the good stuff. They finally ate it but not very hardily. If I offer them 4 different treats at one time, they always will eat this last and sometimes leave it for later. I bought Blue Buffalo food, and they won't eat it at all. I have large breed Labrador mix breed dogs.

We have 4-dogs and each one enjoys this treat. We tried so many different types of dog biscuits because they would refuse to eat their snack . This is the only treat our dogs enjoy and does not hesitate gobbling up. The product is really great and our 4-dogs are proof of this.

I've bought Blue Health Bars in every flavor for my dogs in the past and have always been happy with them. However, these are as hard as a brick (really, they are) and my two 100+ pound dogs have a tough time eating them.

The box is huge & comes with two individually wrapped bags. My golden retriever loves these. They’re kinda large for a small dog but my havanese likes them too. Good price too

My dog loves these treats. I bought a small bag at first. I was going to buy more when this large box appeared in Sam’s ad. I made an excellent choice.