These treats look like cookies. I have two small dogs and they like them. They are kind of messy though. They crumble. I keep the treats in a big cookie jar. Over half of the treats are already crumbled. I went back to a smaller harder treat. They work much better.

My dogs love these Blue Buffalo Health Bar treats. Unfortunately, Sam's Club decided to quit carrying them in the club. So now I have to pay shipping which makes them as expensive as when you buy them at the regular store, so no benefit from having to pay a membership fee to shop at Sam's. I also receive the boxes with many more (significant amount) broken treats and crumbs due to them having to be shipped. So, in conclusion, the treats are good, Sam's Club disappoints yet again.

My girls just love these health bars. They smell amazing too. I will continue to buy these as long as my girls keep jumping with excitement everytime they see the white bag come out. I've also let the bulldog next door try them, he loves them too. I think this is a Winner!!!

My dog loves these, and I feel good about letting her have them. I break them up and keep them in a jar by the door. When guests come in, I have them take one piece and she has to sit, not jump on them before she gets it. Her behavior has improved immensely since we started this. And these biscuits are a “high value” treat to her, so she will do what she has to in order to get them. I also use them for rewards for other things as well.

Too tough to bite for my Maltese and .dachshund. Great brand name

My two large dogs love these health bars. They are very picky on snacks and wont eat most of the other "dog bone snacks "

Our little dog love these treats but we split them as they are for large or medium sized dogs. Break easily for my girls to share.

My dogs won't eat these treats. They may be “healthier” but doesn’t matter if the dogs don’t like them. They smell horrible.

Great bacon smell! My dogs who don’t eat dog biscuits at all love them! Rosie begs for more since her first taste.

The 5 lb. box is back! My dogs love these crunchy biscuits. Only the 3.5 lb. boxes were available for several months for the price of the 5 lb. box. Shortage?