This is a good peanut butter if you like peanut butters like Jif. Personally, I usually buy sugar free peanut butter but Sams Club doesn't sell sugar free peanut butter unfortunately. I am not sure what other reviewers were talking about but it is not thin. It has the texture of a no stir peanut butter like Jif, Skippy, Reese and all the other ones. I don't think I will be purchasing this again because it is not sugar free.

We loved this peanut butter because it was delicious, such a good price and had simple ingredients (peanuts and salt). Now, it contains sugar and palm oil which not only drastically changed the texture but also the taste and nutritional value. Boo, Sam's Club. Boo.

Alright, buckle up, peanut butter lovers, because I've just experienced a peanut butter revelation! I'm talking about a creamy, dreamy, nutty masterpiece that has redefined my PB expectations. This isn't your average, run-of-the-mill peanut butter. Oh no. This is a symphony of roasted peanuts, perfectly ground to a velvety smoothness that glides across your tongue like a warm hug. The aroma alone is enough to send you into a peanut butter-induced trance. The flavor? Forget everything you thought you knew. It's rich, robust, and undeniably peanutty, with just the right balance of sweetness and a hint of natural salt that elevates it to pure culinary bliss. It's the kind of peanut butter that makes you close your eyes and savor every single bite. Whether you're spreading it on toast, dipping apple slices, or just eating it straight from the jar (no judgment here!), this peanut butter is an absolute game-changer. It's the perfect blend of texture, flavor, and pure peanut goodness. Seriously, if you haven't tried it yet, you're missing out on a truly awesome and great peanut butter experience. Prepare to be amazed!

When you first open it the PB is really runny, when you get to the bottom it is so stiff you can hardly get it out of the jar. So with the second jar, I have tried to stir it and that's just messy. It was an okay substitute when you couldn't get Jiff but I won't be purchasing this again unless I have no choice.

Tastes good, but quite runny. It ran out of my kid's PB&J. Not a mess I want to deal with every day with a three year old. However, it's perfect for dipping (i.e. apple slices, pretzel rods) and drizzling. True to its name, it does not require stirring.

We really loved this as it is comparable to JIF natural peanut butter. It was a better deal too as JIF is $3.59 for 16 oz and this is about the same price for 40 oz., Not only is this not available in the store or even able to be ordered, but the store shelf labeling has been completely removed which would imply that this product has been removed from the Sam's Club product line-up. This is disappointing. I hope they bring it back.

Really looking forward to this but the consistency is off. I failed to read the label first and after discovering it has PALM OIL I now know why. Palm oil is barely passable in body lotion so no clue why they have decided to put it into food when even wild animals wont eat it It stays thick which is it's selling point

Our whole family loves this peanut butter. It is actually a no stir natural peanut butter. We’ve tried others that need to be stirred every time you open the jar. That is not the case with this brand. One jar last us less than two weeks. It tastes better than the big name brands and has better ingredients.

This peanut butter is delicious: not too salty, not too sweet. Surprise! It tastes like peanuts and reminds me of the peanut butter we made from scratch while living in West Africa. We ran out recently and I couldn't get to the big city to stop by Sam's so I bought another brand from our local store. Yuck! Not only was it extremely sweet and salty, it was also grainy. And if nothing else convinces you this peanut butter is worth a try, this might. My thrifty husband even agreed we could throw out that grainy other brand now that I'be been able to restock with Member's Mark.

This is not a No Stir peanut butter. Be very careful when you take the inner cover off. There is quite a bit of oil separation and you will be wearing it or cleaning it up and the oil is very difficult to clean. It tastes good, but I wouldn't recommend this for a sandwich, due to the fact it is fairly thin. I would buy again, but now I know what it's going to be like.