Jif was removed from the shelves due to a quality problem that Sam's never notified it's customers about. I purchased this thinking it would be a good substitute. I was wrong. While the taste is OK, the consistency and viscosity sub-par. It separates in the "jar" requiring stirring before use. It becomes almost a liquid and runs off the sides of warm toast. I wonder how it would affect baked goods. This is three time deal for us; first, last and only.

This is not a No Stir peanut butter. Be very careful when you take the inner cover off. There is quite a bit of oil separation and you will be wearing it or cleaning it up and the oil is very difficult to clean. It tastes good, but I wouldn't recommend this for a sandwich, due to the fact it is fairly thin. I would buy again, but now I know what it's going to be like.

I didn't realize this was "natural" until I opened it and saw oil sitting on top. I don't buy the natural in any brand because don't like having to stir it before each use. I had nothing to lose because of the money back guarantee so I got out a heavier serving spoon and mixed it thoroughly - including the hard stuff at the bottom. I was surprised that I didn't have to mix it again - not even a little bit. It also tastes great!

I love most Member's Mark products, so I decided to try their creamy peanut butter. Wow, it tastes great and is very creamy. However, after scraping my tongue, brushing my tongue with toothpaste and gargling with mouthwash, I could not get rid of the taste on my tongue and in my mouth. I will not buy this peanut butter again.

I don't know why but when the lockdowns happened with covid, they changed the recipe of this peanut butter or something. It's really runny now. Would probably be good for cooking sauces with but for pb&j /sandwiches it's terrible now. Taste is good but texture sucks.

This is a good peanut butter if you like peanut butters like Jif. Personally, I usually buy sugar free peanut butter but Sams Club doesn't sell sugar free peanut butter unfortunately. I am not sure what other reviewers were talking about but it is not thin. It has the texture of a no stir peanut butter like Jif, Skippy, Reese and all the other ones. I don't think I will be purchasing this again because it is not sugar free.

This peanut butter is GOOD. It's the perfect compromise between the junk and the all-natural ones. It does have sugar and oil so if you're not into that this isn't for you, but if you're looking for one in between that doesn't have 20 ingredients, this is it. It tastes really amazing, it's good for baking and the price is great.

We always bought Wegmans or Safeway’s store brands, but those have been hard to find so we tried this. This is a really good substitute and my husband and son like it a lot. I like it, but my pet conure really loves it. This is our new go to brand. Bird and husband approved!

The only reason for the low star is that on the label it brags to be "no stir" however everything I use it I find myself having to stir the peanut butter because the oils seep to the top. One time it happened within 30 minutes between two sandwiches. Taste is good and if you don't mind stirring it is a good peanut butter.

Good peanut butter we buy regularly