I didn't read the ingredients on this peanut butter before I bought it, thought NATURAL would mean it didn't have any added sugar - I was wrong. It doesn't contain hydrogenated oils, simply peanuts, sugar, palm oil and sea salt. (sea salt impresses people as if it doesn't have the same effects as regular salt - nutritional-wise, just minus iodine. Its a trend that sells.) As far as the taste - its really good, taste like jif to me, I did a side by side taste test. The Sams Peanut Butter is thicker and not as creamy. I would buy it again, price is much better than name brands. Jars are 40 ounces vs 48 oz on the other name brands but still computes to less per ounce . .10 cents VS 07 cents.

My wife bought several jars of this nicely priced Member's Mark peanut butter without looking at the contents. When we went to open one when we ran out of a previous purchase, we noticed the oil had risen to the top. There was a half inch of oil on top. And stirring this NO STIR peanut butter is no picnic. I guess it's been sitting on a warehouse shelf for a number of years already. Best If Used By date is 2 months out, May 25, 2023.

I don't review products but I had to on this one. I have been burned by store brand peanut butter and was so skeptical on trying this. My husband and kids eat a large jar of peanut butter every two weeks, so I was looking for lower cost option since we were going through so much. I picked this up and my husband can't put it down. He says he loves it better than Jif that he used to swear by. I tried it this morning and the taste is phenomenal. I would highly recommend for anyone that is on the fence about purchasing.

I use a hand mixer to blend/incorporate the oils that all "natural" peanut butters have on the surface. After doing so with this brand, this stuff is literally pourable at room temperature. I've never seen this in the numerous "natural" peanut butters I've purchased over the years. It's only redeeming quality is the taste but I won't be purchasing this stuff again due to its room temperature ketchup like viscosity.

I read the ingredients and realized it wasn't a true natural PB before buying. I still gave it a whirl based on the low price for sandwiches and whatnot. It's just not good. Weird taste, gritty, not peanut buttery. If I'm going to eat not actual natural PB, I'll just stick with Jif from now on.

Its 12 cents cheaper where I live right now to buy 2 of the 40 oz Walmart's Natural Peanut butter. For this being a Sam's product it should be a lower price than Walmart. I also believe they shrunk the jars as these used to be 48oz now they are 40oz. This one has added sugar and palm oil. Walmart's has 1g less added sugar than this one while still having Palm oil. The natural label is misleading in this case because Palm oil is not natural. If ingredients are important to you this is not the peanut butter for you.

This is the best peanut butter I have ever eaten. There's no heartburn there's no extra added sugar there's no extra salt it is creamy and delicious and you don't have to stir it. I absolutely love it I think you will too. I definitely recommend it it's way better with natural ingredients compared to some of those name brands.

This is the best pb I've ever had. The taste is phenomenal! Love that it spreads so easily without tearing bread. It has to be stirred periodically but no big deal. We also love it because it's so much easier to get our dog to take her pills. It doesn't stick to one's mouth like other brands. Again, the flavor is fantastic!!

I purchased this for the first time yesterday-I was certainly a skeptic so I made my husband and children do a "taste-test" since we are strictly a Jiff family. My family absolutely LOVED this Peanut Butter! It is much smoother/creamier than Jiff and the flavor is way better. I couldn't stop eating it, I dipped apples and banana slices in it and my daughter had a sandwich as well. The price is also less than Jiff and you get more servings in each jar as well. If you are concerned about calories, this has less than Jiff, it's a win-win! I will be switching indefinitely!

Was very disappointed with this product. The label says “no stir”, but it requires constant stirring because of oil separation. It isn’t firm or spreadable - the consistency is more like dipping sauce. If kept at room temperature, it becomes runny and unpleasant. If you must buy this, stir it well, then keep it in a refrigerator. Only when it’s chilled does it firm up enough to use like normal peanut butter.