I don't review products but I had to on this one. I have been burned by store brand peanut butter and was so skeptical on trying this. My husband and kids eat a large jar of peanut butter every two weeks, so I was looking for lower cost option since we were going through so much. I picked this up and my husband can't put it down. He says he loves it better than Jif that he used to swear by. I tried it this morning and the taste is phenomenal. I would highly recommend for anyone that is on the fence about purchasing.

We really loved this as it is comparable to JIF natural peanut butter. It was a better deal too as JIF is $3.59 for 16 oz and this is about the same price for 40 oz., Not only is this not available in the store or even able to be ordered, but the store shelf labeling has been completely removed which would imply that this product has been removed from the Sam's Club product line-up. This is disappointing. I hope they bring it back.

My local store has been out of Jiff peanut butter, so I purchased Member's Mark instead. The taste is okay but contains palm oil, a saturated fat, and, yes, I should have read the ingredients before purchasing. Just, FYI or TMI: To produce palm oil, the fruit is collected from the trees, which can live an average of 28 to 30 years. Once the trees grow too high, making it difficult to reach the fruit, they are cut down to make room for new trees - which contributes to deforestation of the rainforest. To keep up with the incredibly high demand for the cheaply produced oil, acres of rainforest are being cut down - leading to a loss of animal habitat for endangered species. In the past 16 years, the quest for palm oil has led to the death of an estimated 100,000 orangutans, according to research. Other animals such as elephants, rhinos and tigers are also at risk. Disappointed Sam's feels the need to use palm oil when there are other alternatives such as vegetable oil.

From the time I purchased and opened up this peanut butter the “No Stir” is a lie. First time opening the oil was all in top and spilled. Every time I open it has to be stirred. I should have returned it. I am going to donate since I hate dealing with stirring.

I read the ingredients and realized it wasn't a true natural PB before buying. I still gave it a whirl based on the low price for sandwiches and whatnot. It's just not good. Weird taste, gritty, not peanut buttery. If I'm going to eat not actual natural PB, I'll just stick with Jif from now on.

This is a good peanut butter if you like peanut butters like Jif. Personally, I usually buy sugar free peanut butter but Sams Club doesn't sell sugar free peanut butter unfortunately. I am not sure what other reviewers were talking about but it is not thin. It has the texture of a no stir peanut butter like Jif, Skippy, Reese and all the other ones. I don't think I will be purchasing this again because it is not sugar free.

Disappointed after purchasing this peanut butter, I should've read the label more carefully instead of zoning in on its good price. Peanut butter spread, never heard of such. Also, how can this be no stir with an inch of oil on top? It's Jif next time for me no matter what it costs.

Tastes good, but quite runny. It ran out of my kid's PB&J. Not a mess I want to deal with every day with a three year old. However, it's perfect for dipping (i.e. apple slices, pretzel rods) and drizzling. True to its name, it does not require stirring.

It's great tasting peanut butter but it's covered in oil at the top even though the label clearly says "no stir". No matter how hard you try you still spill some oil on the counter while stirring it. Also by the bottom of the jar it gets dry because there is no way for you to mix all that oil back in evenly.

This is the best peanut butter I have ever eaten. There's no heartburn there's no extra added sugar there's no extra salt it is creamy and delicious and you don't have to stir it. I absolutely love it I think you will too. I definitely recommend it it's way better with natural ingredients compared to some of those name brands.