Love this peanut butter. We have only eaten Skippy Natural for at least a decade now. This is slightly smoother and ever so slightly sweeter??? Unlike the skippy natural, you really do not need to stir it AT ALL!!! My husband appreciates that. Fabulous, fresh roasted peanut taste and a wonderful substitute for skippy natural that saves us a few dollars in our large household. Have you seen the JIF to-go peanut butter cups? Buy some 2 oz cups with lids and fill with this for work or travel! Member’s Mark, you hit this one out of the ballpark!

Good flavor. No difference from the name brands I've tried. I have re-ordered this a couple times now. However, I've had settling in the product requiring me to do some stirring. Even with the stirring, this leads to inconsistency in the texture and creaminess between the top 80% and the bottom. While most of the jar is rich and creamy, the product on the bottom is far more dense and thicker. To me this is nothing more than an inconvenience, given that it's 1/2 the price of name brands.

The Member's Mark Natural Creamy Peanut Butter is just as good as other name-brand ones, but at almost half the price. It is very creamy, tastes great, and made only from natural ingredients. I bought this 2-pack just a little over what I have been paying for a single jar of JIF.

This PB has a very similar taste/texture to Jif Natural. My husband is a PB lover and the only PB he will ever eat is Jif. We made the switch to Jif natural a few years ago and he likes it better than regular Jif (never thought that would happen). So when we tried this PB, he was surprised that he really can't tell the difference. Also this MM one is still 'all natural', which I like. So, when I can buy 1 Jif natural or 2 of these MM for the same price, both are natural and taste great - That's a no-brainer! Good job on this MM PB Sam's Club.

I’ve used different types of natural no stir peanut butters and they’ve either needed to be stirred despite advertisements or they were so yucky chalky and bland. This particular brand surprised me soooo much!!! I mean I love it!!!! No stir ! And it’s delicious and natural!!! All around win!! I highly recommend!

This peanut butter taste very good and is comparable with similar natural brands. If you're used to buying the others, as I am, you expect to have to stir a little to mix the oil back in. So it's not unusually oily. The price is a very good value. I will certainly continue to purchase this product.

We've tried replacing it several times when it has been out of stock for shipping as the Sam's in Madison, WI closed many years ago and it is inconvenient to get to a physical store, but we just can't go back to any of the other brands. We love the taste, consistency and value!

My husband loves peanut butter! The last 4-5 years we have switched from the name brand, peanut butter to members mark natural for many reasons. 1st taste, calories, fat & sugar content. The price for 2 isn’t bad either. I make sure we never run low much less out!

Favorite PB!!! This is the best peanut butter ever! After trying this a couple years ago, my family won’t eat any other brand. It’s perfectly creamy, sweet, and salty. I have gotten several people to try it as well, and they all prefer it to any other.

I liked the fact that this peanut butter was made out of natural wholesome ingredients without chemicals or additives. I had tried natural peanut butter in the past and found it either very oily or very dry. This peanut butter maintains a more consistent texture and I was pleased to discover it was quite tasty, too.