I have been enjoying peanut butter for 70 years and usually ate the healthier choices in brands. This peanut butter matches the fat, carb and sodium content of the “healthy brand” but is the best tasting peanut butter I have ever tasted. I bought two for my daughter who at first was annoyed that they were so large and there were two of them. She has limited storage. After 3 months she is on her 4th jar and my granddaughter loves it so much she eats it by the spoonful for snacks. Please never discontinue this product. My husband made me buy 6 in reserve because he is afraid Sams would run out or discontinue it!

I’ve used different types of natural no stir peanut butters and they’ve either needed to be stirred despite advertisements or they were so yucky chalky and bland. This particular brand surprised me soooo much!!! I mean I love it!!!! No stir ! And it’s delicious and natural!!! All around win!! I highly recommend!

Great product! I always have this on hand. I mix it with Sam's honey and Sam's Almond butter. I keep it on my table to eat on Ezekiel bread toast or spoonfuls by itself. A great source of protein for every meal, and I feel better with the protein. We highly recommend these products!

NO ONE knows this is all natural in my household! It tastes exactly like the big brand name and has none of the crazy ingredients. It does have some sugar added, but we can deal with that. Everyone loves this peanutbutter, including our dogs and two cockatoos!

My family prefers this peanut butter over the big brands. My youngest son thanked me and hugged me when I bought his favorite. I can't imagine switching to a different brand after the Member's Mark. Its perfect. Smooth and creamy Not too sweet. Just right.

Tasty peanut butter but the labeling stating that no stirring needed is misleading. There is some oil separation on top. More importantly, if you don't stir periodically, the peanut butter at bottom of jar is too dry to spread. Not a big deal to stir at every use.

Love this peanut butter! Best part is it is not made with soy oil! Companies will do anything to save money! Including not using peanut oil in PEANUT butter. However, this peanut is authentic and true to it's creamy label. My advice: still stir! Unless you want a dryer content when you reach the bottom of the jar.

Since we “discovered” the Members Mark peanut butter, no other brand has been in our house. The rich full flavor, the very creamy texture, and that wonderful smooth spread. I try to get everyone to give this peanut butter a try, to the point some of them are tired of hearing about it.

This peanut butter taste very good and is comparable with similar natural brands. If you're used to buying the others, as I am, you expect to have to stir a little to mix the oil back in. So it's not unusually oily. The price is a very good value. I will certainly continue to purchase this product.

If all things equal my favorite PB is Smart Balance but it's so close and MM is such a better value it's the way I roll. Perfect no stir sets on my counter all the time delicious. The only negative is it has Palm oil and SB is strictly cane sugar. This is the only reason I took away star.