Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Natural Creamy Peanut Butter, 40 oz., 2 pk. for
Member's Mark Natural Creamy Peanut Butter, 40 oz., 2 pk.
4.7 out of 5 stars
stars8,038 ratings2,277 reviews
  1. 5 stars84% (6,742)
  2. 4 stars9% (752)
  3. 3 stars3% (246)
  4. 2 stars1% (99)
  5. 1 star2% (199)

Member photos

  • +26 images
Sort by |
Showing 141-150 of 2,277 reviews
Nov 4, 2024
V Bell
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

we like the taste

Every bit as good quality as the name brand peanut butters. It's a natural peanut butter, but doesn't separate like many do. It does have sugar in it, so it's not just peanuts, but we like the taste so much better than the purely peanut varieties.

Helpful?4J8UA77KAVJO7874219579
May 8, 2021
esb1426
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

A good substitute for JIF Natural Creamy

Tastes almost exactly like JIF Natural Creamy. My (picky) kids couldn't tell the difference and there are fewer calories and grams of sugar in the Sam's brand.

Helpful?4J8UA77KAVJO7874219579
Nov 30, 2021
MomtoBrady
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Great Taste, Great Value!

The price is hard to beat! It is just as good as any name brand natural peanut butters in the store. I love it and will definitely be buying this again!

Helpful?4J8UA77KAVJO7874219579
Oct 25, 2020
Dare
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

MM peanut butter is worth the price

Once I tasted this peanut butter, I stopped buying just any brand of peanut butter. This all natural product is excellent and the taste is what makes a difference

Helpful?4J8UA77KAVJO7874219579
Nov 21, 2021
Qarol
4 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Needs Stirring

Great flavor but I took away one star because the texture is not consistent through to the bottom. If you don't stir, by the time you get to the last quarter of the jar, the bottom gets as dense as cheese.

Helpful?4J8UA77KAVJO7874219579
Jul 22, 2023
BennysMom
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Better than the other leading peanut butter

Better than the other leading peanut butter. I would never have tried this except that there was a shortage of PB a while back. WE were always true to Jif for many years.

Helpful?4J8UA77KAVJO7874219579
May 14, 2026
Rodlynne
1 out of 5 stars review

No Stir? Every time I opened the jar I had to stir this peanut butter spread. I even tried mixing it up in my stand mixer then separating it into smaller jars. Whether it was week or just a day, I had to stir before use. The taste is acceptable, but it's messy and inconvenient. I won't be purchasing this product again.

Helpful?4J8UA77KAVJO7874219579
May 16, 2026
William
2 out of 5 stars review

Good product gone to crap.

I have been buying Member's Mark Natural Creamy Peanut Butter, 40 oz., 2 pk. for a very long time. We love it, well loved it anyways. The last few months we have been getting crap products. It started with one that was half oil. Returned that one. This last shipment they have been thinner than usual. I do not know if it is a quality control issue or they are sitting in a hat warehouse and have separated. Could be a combination of both but I think it is a QC issue. EIther way we are going back to the Aldi brand peanut butter. What a shame.

Helpful?4J8UA77KAVJO7874219579
Apr 30, 2026
Richard
4 out of 5 stars review

The Best Peanut Butter you will find.

Maybe the best Natural Peanut Butter (non flavored) available. Take the challenge - post your opinion. If you do not agree after opening first jar - donate unopened 2nd jar to your Food Bank. The downside and why I don't give it 5 stars is: Sam's does not make this available in all stores. In my market- only 2 out of 5 show it available in stores. I think they should offer free "to store" shipping when a product is available and they choose not to have at all stores. I would love Sam's (not Ai) to explain.

Helpful?4J8UA77KAVJO7874219579
Jan 16, 2024
Mikefrmgarner
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Best Ever

Since we “discovered” the Members Mark peanut butter, no other brand has been in our house. The rich full flavor, the very creamy texture, and that wonderful smooth spread. I try to get everyone to give this peanut butter a try, to the point some of them are tired of hearing about it.

Helpful?4J8UA77KAVJO7874219579