We've used this CLUMPING litter for many years. Currently have 3 cats -- have never had a problem of them not using the kitty litter. This litter IS the best deal around as far as we know. Only one time do I recall "trying" another brand from another supplier because of special purchase pricing made it comparable in price; however it did NOT have the same qualities! This Sam's litter clumps better and IS better at keeping odors down. We normally keep at least 2-3 on hand, but this last month found ourselves running out -- nearing the bottom of our last bucket! Not to fear, Sam's was on our schedule, BUT their shelves were BARE! They called another Dayton OH area Sam's -- 15 miles away that "had 18" ... Only to get there and find out their computer was wrong! Even online was OUT OF STOCK! Fortunately a couple days later, ONLINE was in stock. We ordered 6 -- with FREE shipping! Wonder what the FedEx driver thought -- probably figured we have a ton of cats! LOL We got by in part until they came because this litter does such a good job even when the kitty litter containers were getting pretty low -- just kept taking out their litter. Needless to say, HOPE Sam's never discontinues this!

I had been using Fresh Step from Sams for several years until this came out recently. I decided to give it a try and wish I hadn't. It says it has more clumping power, but I don't believe it. It had almost NO CLUMPING,,, and the odor after cleaning out the litter box was almost enough to run me out of the house. Almost all of Sam's products are very dependable, but this one misses the mark by miles!!

After reading the other reviews, I'm glad to see that I'm not the only one who has noticed what has to be a change in "recipe". I thought because I added a third cat pan it was the reason for the dust but when I had two, the dust was minimal. I couldn't understand how the third left a film that looked like I haven't dusted in years! Other than the dust, it works great. Traps the smell, clumps well, and is a great price.

I decided to give this a try one day and it was the worst idea I've had in a long time! You better be wearing a respirator when you scoop using this stuff because this creates off-the-charts dust! My poor kitties have been having to breathe it! I wouldn't be a bit surprised if there isn't a lawsuit in the future over this terrible product. I'm going to have to dump both my cat boxes and start over, and I'm not even using Members Mark 100% yet! I've only added to what I already had! But it quickly contaminated my boxes to the point where I can't even breathe. Just watch the video!

Please do not bother buying this litter unless you have a barn fan in the window and even then I caution you. This is the dustiest cat litter ever invented! As I poured it there were plumes of dust in the air. I could feel a layer on my clothes, hair, up my nose, and in my mouth as I tried an alternate path for oxygen! It's not worth the savings, it's terrible! It also DOES NOT cover the odor especially urine. I wouldn't expect this quality from such a huge company. I'm returning to my previous cat litter as it's not worth the $6 I saved.

Its a good price but you get what you pay for. It doesn't clump well at all with cat urine. Doesn't keep the (# 2 smell) smell concealed as well as Scoop Away does. I have 4 cats and gave this litter a try. using what I have left and going back to Scoop Away cat litter. Few extra bucks is worth it. This kitty litter is horrible. I do not recommend this to anyone

I was hoping that this kitty litter was everything it said on the packaging. It definitely is not! It does not conceal any orders at all there is no fresh fragrance whatsoever, and when skipping the kitty box it feels like the dust from the litter is filling my lungs. This is the worst cat litter I have ever used

Have used for years, but this new batch sends up a dust cloud to rival Mt. St Helens that leaves a dust film on anything around it when filling or as the cat uses it. I must hold my breath when scooping the clumps, so I feel sorry for my kitty as he has to breathe this in an enclosed space. Dumped immediately and will not be buying again unless the formula changes. Not worth the cheaper price anymore.

This litter is so so dusty. Only use if you don't plan on using the room for anything else because everything will be covered in dust. Also, be warned that cleaning the litter box creates a dust everywhere and it's hard not to breath it and it's disgusting.

I have been buying this cat litter for years and just purchased the "new improved 4 in 1 formula. It doesn't clump at all like the ones before and my house smells like cat urine the moment I walk in. I am unable to scoop up a "clump", just a few small pieces that don't fall through the scoop. I will be looking for a different brand.