I would give this ZERO stars if it were possible. The dust clouds rise 5-6 feet in the air just from scooping. Product is nearly unusable. Dust settles all over on nearby furniture, walls, and window sills over 6-7 feet away...it's disgusting and ridiculous. Odor control is equally terrible. Absolutely the WORST cat litter I've ever used, and I will never buy again. I was going to donate the remaining to my local animal shelter, but, in good conscience, I can't because this product is THAT BAD. Steer clear and buy anything else other than this. I'll be switching back to Scoop Away.

I bought this litter in hopes that it would work just as good as tidy cat but for a smaller price. Unfortunately it does not. The urine does not clump but sinks to the bottom and crumbles when you try to scoop it. It does not take away the odor either. We scoop every day so my problem is not due to non-maintenance. Will not buy again.

We typically buy Scoop Away at Costco, but we needed litter now, and we saw this at Sams. I quickly looking at the overall ratings on line and with 4 stars, thought it would be a safe bet. WRONG! just moving the litter shovel through it slowly creates a major dust cloud. In addition, it clumps into clay balls that easily fall apart when you are trying to remove them. The clumps also stick to the sides and bottom of the litter box, making removal very difficult. The odor control was fine, but that doesn't outweigh the dust and clumping issues. In summary, never again!

If you want a no tracking and tight clumping cat litter then this is your best choice. The litter clumps so tight I needed to purchase a heavy gage scooper to pick up everything. I have 2 cats and have tried every type, brand and price. My club was sold out so we “settled” for a named brand from the pet store and I now have tiny granules on the floor. Best litter and at a great price.

I normally use Scoop Away but picked this up during the Quarantine fun. I had used this previously and thought I would try it again as it is almost half the cost. That is because the clumping is non-existent. It just becomes a yucky dusty mess when you try and scoop the urine. Sadly I will not be purchasing this again.

I have been buying this kitty litter for quite awhile, after finding out my vet team used it at the office and home. I was extremely pleased with the litter. Then, something changed. First, I noticed about 3-4 months ago that the litter was a darker color. Then, I noticed it did not clump as well, and that I needed to do a litter change more frequently. I thought maybe I had a bad batch (as i buy several at a time), but the latest I bought has the same issues. I do not feel I could recommend this at this time.

I always bought the old one 3x odor control herbal essence, and it was great. Never any odor. This 4 in 1 Formula is the worst cat litter I ever bought. Changed the litter in the box Thrusday, on Friday the box and room smelled so bad even with no cat waste in it. This stuff needs to be discontinued and the old herbal essence put back in the stores. I have a litter box in the basement with the old 3x odor control herbal essence and it is great, no odors and everytime you scoop out the waste is smells as fresh as the first day you put it int the litter box. Members Mark 4 in 1 Formula is a waste of money. Have to buy another brand and clean out the litter box again after only 2 days.

For a little while now, the litter just doesn't work. It more or less just masses into on big, awful pile which, when you go to scoop, breaks up into small pieces that won't stick together. There's barely any odor control, and the thing is incredibly heavy but doesn't last the week. Total waste of money.

We've been using this kitty litter for years. It disappeared from the stores for a couple months, now it's back and you can keep it! Horrible! No clumping, smells - impossible to clean boxes! Cats are starting to misbehave to the point this "crap" is getting the boot to the curb.

I needed kitty litter, and my Sam's was out of my usual Fresh Step, so I bought a bucket of this. Odor control seems OK, not sure about the dust because that's not really a factor for me, but scoopability is poor, at best. The Fresh Step litter holds the clumps much better than this product. Every time I scoop (every day and sometimes 2X/day) some of the clumps break up and are redistributed into the "clean" litter, and are too small to pick up with my scooper. I am quite disappointed in my purchase. I know I can return it, but I'll probably keep this bucket since I only bought the one. If my Sam's is out of Fresh Step the next time, I'll either order it online or buy it elsewhere.