I'm not sure what has happened with this litter. The product was never a consistent grain, sometimes it was course, other times it was dusty, but at least it did it's job. However, this last batch I purchased has been so bad that I won't purchase it again. There's no odor control, and no clumping at all! With a multi-cat household, this has been the worst as far as odor and sifting. Buyer beware!

Clumps well and does good with containing the smell but I have never used a litter with so much dust! It floofs when the cats use it and soooooo much when I scoop it that it will be up my nose forever! I won't be buying again because of how dusty it is, sad because it was a good price too.

Great litter. Clumps well and there is virtually NO SMELL unless you don't scoop your box at least a couple of times a week and change liner & litter every week or two. Only issue is the weight, of 42lbs, making it hard for seniors to lift off shelf to get it into a shopping cart or scooter chair. I'll not buy any another brand of litter unless this one at Sam's goes away. Would be really great if this product was also offered at the Walmart stores as well.

I like the litter. My Sam?s didn?t have it on my last visit so I attempted to order online and do in store pick up and it was unavailable. I hope they get it back ASAP. It clumps well, easy clean up and and I keep 3 boxes for 2 cats. The only down fall it does have a lot of dust but all the brands I?ve used does also. Very good litter for the price

This litter has always been my go-to litter for a 2 cat household with 2 litter boxes. Something has changed. The litter is so very dusty I need to cover my face when cleaning the box. The dust is that bad. The room where the litter boxes are located is covered in dust every day and the dust is not like just regular dust, but requires dusting and then wiping down with water to get it all up. I don't know what has happened with this member's mark brand, but something is not the same.

The price for this litter is excellent, probably the best price I could find. The only downside and it was a deal breaker for me, it is way to dusty!!!! My wife couldn't scoop it because it produced way to much dust. If you don't mind the dust and don't mind dusting every surface in your room, this litter is for you.

I usually like members marks products but this is a definite fail, this has to be the worst cat litter I've ever used, doesn't clump very well, unbearably dusty and no odor control at all. It's not a bad price but I wouldn't buy it again at any price.

it creates plume of dust when cleaning but otherwise works as described, tight clumps doesn't track. but the dust = -4 stars I brought 2 since it was on sale if you brought 4 member mark items. I use my second container now for extra weight during winter drives and/or if I need traction in snowy/ice. Also, serves as good way to treat foggy windows. put it ziploc baggy and open it when you turn on the car and place the baggy by the windshield. This winter extra use +1 star I am going back to tidy cats Glade or 24/7 that sams sells as that works better

I've been pleased with many other Member's Mark items so I tried this with high hopes. The texture is very strange, almost like big granules of sand, and very dusty. The litter does not clump very well, and stays wet so it breaks into a ton of pieces when attempting to scoop it out. Also, there is basically no odor control with this brand.

We have been using this litter for years with great success! Solid odor control and excellent clumping. New formula is UNACCEPTABLE!!! DOES NOT CLUMP!! AT ALL!! It is more like oil dry that cat litter. Not sure why they fooled around with this but it took a good product in the wrong direction. I have two other buckets but not sure of the quality of these. Have not experienced the dust that others have.