Our dogs really like these. We have 2 mixed breed rescues that are medium sized (42 & 54 lbs). I’m giving 3 stars because they eat them very quickly. Only last a few minutes

These are a harder bone/chew that take longer for my 115 pound dog to chew up, which is always a good thing. He loves his snacks so the longer they can last, the better. I like that they aren't rawhide or have corn or wheat.

My dogs absolutely love these. The treats keep our dogs busy for quite a while. They really love to gnaw on them. When they hear me getting into the packaging they get very excited. Sam's has the best pricing on these.

I have been buying this treat for my dogs for years. I am disappointed that Sam's does not carry this in-store anymore. Now with a minimum purchase required for free shipping, this is harder to get. Sam's need to bring it back to the store.

I got these as a Christmas present for my brothers VERY VERY picky Great Dane. He only likes certain treats. He LOVED these!! His birthday is in March he will be getting more!

The smell is too strong, and my dog won't even taste it. He makes a nauseated face and turns away. But I have another dog (one that will eat literally any and everything) who will eat this. So, I guess it gets a three.

The dogs love the bones. They’re medium size dogs do the bones keep them busy chewing and chomping for a while. Made by Purina do it’s a trusted brand and one of the dogs eats Purina dog food.

These are great bones to keep your dog entertained for a bit. My dog has them eaten within five minutes. It does not give him smelling gas either which is a huge plus!

These chews last my dogs much longer than other similar shaped chew sticks. These are much harder and so the dogs chew on them longer. It seems to be a much better value for the money on how long it takes my dogs to eat them.

My dogs really loved this. The sticks are about 4.25" long and .75 to 1 inch wide. It is hard to find a treat that doesn't have chicken or fish oil in it. Being a food product, it lasts about 5-10 minutes to eat.