Dogs love them

Dog refuses to eat these. Never refuses to eat anything I give her. Must be terrible.

Very dry and crumbly. Very few of the actual treats are in one piece. Won't purchase again.

These are human grade treats. My Winnie loves them. I feel better giving her a treat that's not nasty junk and made in America..

All my dogs love these treats! They do crumble easily but that makes them work to clean up the mess

I really wanted to feed my new puppy wholesome foods and treats. For some reason my puppy ate one and wont eat them anymore. ☹️

This arrived all broken and mostly in crumbs. Some of the pieces are useable. Only a handful of whole treats.

These give my dog diarrhea and upset stomach. Never used to happen until I started giving him these treats

Our dog loves them. He's got a lot of food allergies, sweet potatoes, wheat most grains, anything that has wings or swims. So all poultry and fish is out. This is one of only 2 treats that he's not allergic too. And he loves them

Our dogs gag on these but eventually eat them. Occasionally throw up. I tasted one and found it dry and mealy. Could not taste the peanut butter. I will not buy again.