I have tried the MilkBone "grain-free" for my sensitive skinned GSD, and he just itched like crazy. The treats from Member's Mark, however have been AWESOME! My dogs love the peanut butter flavor. They're small enough that I can break them in half for training treats (I have large dogs) and large enough that two stacked together make a nice reward without too many calories. Mainly I'm just very happy to finally find a treat for my GSD that doesn't make his skin crawl. For those interested we feed him Pro Plan for sensitive skin and stomach, salmon flavor. Cheers :)

My dog has profound allergies and it's a nightmare trying to find foods and treats that don't contain an ingredient she can't eat. I used to buy the ultra premium Wet Noses brand of cookies and when I read the ingredients on these, I found they're identical. The cookies are the same size and texture, too and my dog loves them. I did take off one star because they're based on pea protein which has recently been involved in causing heart problems in dogs. However, since these are treats and not food, I'm comfortable that a couple a day will be all right. Everything in moderation.

We’ve been buying these for over a year and the last batch we just bought was about a month ago. We noticed all 3 of our dogs started constantly itching and assumed it was fall allergies. We tried everything and the hot spots were so bad. When medication wouldn’t stop their discomfort we started leaning towards what they were eating. Since these are only 5 ingredients and not chicken based we assumed they were fine, but it was the last thing to look at. So on a whim we stopped giving them these biscuits and the itching stopped a few hours later. It’s been 2 days since and they’ve dramatically improved. Something was changed in this batch and unfortunately we will never be buying these again. Quality control is apparently not as important anymore.

From reviewers who said these were crumbly, soft, broken up ... not so in the box I received. I was hoping all those comments were true because I found them all in one piece and very hard to break up into pieces. I use pieces as training and reward treats throughout the day. Great to coax my stubborn ACD puppy in her crate for down time or to come back into the house. CON: They smell go good, everytime I open the canister, they make me crave peanut butter cookies.

We usually get the Pumpkin flavored treats but they only had the Peanut Butter treats available this time. We have tried a few times now, each time my husky gets terrible loose stool and becomes lethargic for a couple of days. I think we may have received a bad batch.

My girls love the treats but seems the last few boxes I have purchased have more bits and pieces than full bones! With my 110 lb lab a little piece will not due so she ends up getting a handful of pieces instead of just one bone. Not saying this is done purposefully but I do go through these treats much quicker that way…. Just saying.

I had high hopes for these but they give my dog horrible, painful diarrhea. After eating these bones our dog will wake you up 3 or 4 times a night to go out and very little happens every time. I thought I may be wrong and reintroduced these treats to him a few weeks later but had the exact same experience each time.

Sadly I will never be buying these for my 2 dogs again. Huge box of treats and they would've been a great find and great value for money IF there had been more than 7 unbroken biscuits in the entire box. And no, I'm not joking. When I opened the packaging and saw all of the tiny broken pieces, I honestly went through and searched for any whole treat I could find and that's the number I came up with. Complete waste of money for me. Maybe I was the unlucky one since there are so many positive reviews, but I definitely won't be trying them again.

I have five 60+ lb dogs. I gave them one of these. Most of them broke them into pieces and didn’t eat them. 1 had ate a few small pieces and she ended up with bloody diarrhea. I was going to give them to the birds but I was afraid they would kill them. Put in trash.

This box of treats comes w/2 cellophane bags of treats. All of the bones in both bags were broken into pieces. What a shame, I bought them Bcz it's hard to find treats that are reasonably priced and not full of garbage. I won't repurchase and unfortunately wouldn't recommend.