My dogs love these! I have 3 dogs, while they aren't too picky these are by far their favorite. I like them because of the ingredients. We've been giving these to our dogs for more than a year. I haven't found them anywhere but Sam's, so please keep providing them!

Although they are a bit tough to break in half, my dogs only get them as treats through the day, they are not tough for my dogs to eat. The peanut butter smell makes me believe they have a good amount of peanut butter in them. I buy them online now because I never know when they will be out of stock in the store.

Great dog treats! The company that makes the treats for Member's Mark is a wholesome company that is very conscious of what goes into every treat! However, buyer beware if you order them from Sam's Club.com. Our treats were put in a box with heavier items (canned goods), which smashed the treats to small pieces due to not enough packing material. When reporting the issue to Sam's Club, they have not made any attempt to contact me regarding the damage incurred.

These are the best ...my Malshi gets respiratory issues with other treats, asthmatic type stuff...not with these...I like the purity of them....she also does so well with the Christmas version Sam's puts out but so relieved to see these back and hope they will always be available and never ever change the formula...Bella loves them and is counting on you, there is little I can give her...even food wise, its a challenge....I have to make her people food, organic...we love our dogs we do what we have to

I’ve bought these for a long time. My dog likes them. BUT they are broken in half and more. I put them in a treat ball and the fall out because they are broken. The bag I just opened has them all broken. I can’t grind even one that is whole. So if you don’t mind broken they’re ok but frustrating if you need them whole.

I’ve been buying this for the last two years. My dog still loves these treats. I like that they stay crisp in my airtight container and do not have an odor. Best of all, these treats have never upset my dog’s tummy. They are a very good value for my money.

I used to buy these in the store when they had them in-store. Now they are only online for shipping. The problem w this is that the shipping process breaks "most" of the dog biscuits. I have a large dog that wants the full biscuit and I don't want to deal with all the broken pieces when giving them out as treats. I estimate that 70% of the dog biscuits are broken now that they can only be shipped to you as a Members Mark product. They should sell these in the store and this would alleviate this problem. Really frustrating.

They're great, and I don't worry about feeding my dogs weird crap. The box comes with two bags of treats, so they stay fresher. We decant them into a cereal container with a lid. They're fairly easy to split in half with your hands, though they don't always split perfectly down the middle since they're a harder treat. My dogs love them, and it occupies them for a few minutes too :)

i have ordered these several times. dog love them but today when I pulled out 3 biscuts out for my working dogs i found 2 hooked together by "string" and the ends of one had shreds of plastic coming out of them! i was mortified that I was.feeding my dogs these. Never again. to say I'm disappointed in a brand that boast all natural ingredients and no fillers. who knew it had this.crap in it! Needless to say you have lost a loyal customer.

Only giving three stars because I had to return one box because the dog bones were burnt and my dogs would not eat them. I have had them before and the dogs like them. I did get a refund on the burned batch, and the next box was a little better, but still a bit over done but the dogs to eat them. Hoping it’s just a one time thing with a bad batch.