Not too hard, but hard enough to help clean Rocky's teeth. He loves the taste.

My dog loves these peanut butter treats! They are made from all natural ingredients, very healthy treats!

Dogs do not like this. My dogs run from it when I brought them out. I give it to my little guy and he’ll spit it out and run from it.

Haven’t tried them, but the dogs seem to like them! Don’t know they have ever turned down a treat though?

This is the second time I bought these and my dog will not eat them. She takes it in her mouth, looks at me, and drops it on the floor.

Our dogs love these but they arrived all broken. We have bullies and we have to count our fingers when we give them these treats.

My dog loves it.

I purchased two boxes of these treats.The first box contained about 50% broken pieces. My dog liked them so much I bought a second box thinking that the first box was just bad luck. Not the case, the second box had about 90% broken pieces. My dog swallowed one of the pieces without chewing it and chocked. I will never buy them again.

My dog really looks forward to these treats. And best of all they agree with his GI tract. But for his size, an whole treat is his portion. Unfortunately, most of these bones are broken into pieces See my photo as an example of one of a newly opened bag (two bags are in a box.) Try explaining to your dog why they only get a piece and not the whole bone. Really disappointed with this product. They are selling mostly rejects at full price.

Woof woof! As a furry four-legged friend, I can confidently say that these treats are the real deal. They're delicious, healthy, and they make me wag my tail with excitement every time I see the bag. I'm a discerning pup with a refined palate, and I can tell you that these treats are made from only the finest ingredients. They're packed with protein and flavor, and they never leave me feeling hungry or unsatisfied. But it's not just the taste that makes these treats so great. They're also good for me! They're made from real meat and vegetables, with no added preservatives or fillers. My human parents love that they can give me a treat that's not only delicious but also healthy. Whether I'm sitting, staying, or rolling over, I know that a tasty reward is coming my way. These treats have quickly become my favorite, and I'm sure your furry friend will love them too. Woof woof!