I gave it 5 Stars so you'll see the review- My dogs never hated anything more than these treats. My pup who is a vacuum and we have to be quit before he swallows thing spit these out and looked at us like " what is this?"

The dogs love this treat and it helps with there teeth. I've been buying them for years. Why did you suddenly quit carrying them in the store? If they are so popular that would be alot more sales.

Just about every dog I give these to loves them. I use them in my pet care business and give them to my own dogs. As soon as you open the bag, you can smell the peanut butter. Dogs have never experienced any GI distress from these so I trust them.

Both of our shepherds love these! Nice simple ingredients as shepherds are known for their sensitive stomachs. Some arrive broken, but that's fine. Great price for a treat that doesn't upset their stomach and that they enjoy. I get all of their attention on a walk if I just carry one in my pocket!!

I bought these treats a couple months ago for a bed time snack for our two bulldogs. According to the box, I am allowed to give them each 10 treats a day but I was only giving them 1 a day, or should I say, night. After going through 70% of the package, both dogs developed diarrhea. The younger recovered after 4 days suffering. The older developed so much diarrhea that it became fully liquid and just squirted like a faucet. She turned to vomiting so much that it became clear. And this happened several times an hour. Being indoor dogs, what a mess to clean up and do so often in each day, but more importantly, despite a gallon of water, the dog became so dehydrated according to the vet along with being delirious and will no longer eat. She has a vet visit now scheduled in few days to determine end of life. Do not get this product under any circumstance, and if I could, I would seek legal action, but all I can prove is I bought the package, the only change in diet, and the fact I have sick dogs. I cannot, without a doubt, prove the connection between product and dog illness, though I know it to be so. Therefore, we are losing our pet and no remedy for it.

Love that these treats have few ingredients and all natural

I love these for my dogs as there are only 5 ingredients. The dogs love them.

The dogs dont like them Refuse to eat them

Great dog treats with out the problematic additives (like wheat and corn). My dogs love them.

Pup loves these. Great value, also