We wanted to love these, more importantly we wanted our dog to love these. I love that they only have 5 ingredients. Canola oil seems unnecessary, I understand its a cheap "filler". Our dog did NOT like them.

Not sure how it has so many good stars

Only a few whole treats in packag e the rest were crushed.

They are packed in two plastic bags in a box and all broken into pieces

Please bring these back, or dogs love them.

My dog absolutely refuses to eat these treats.

Great treats without a bunch of artificial stuff. Our Golden Retrievers love them.

These treats constipated my dog. She did seem to care much for them either.

These are the best dog treats ever!

Both bags were full of burnt broken biscuits. So disappointed