We have been buying these treats for awhile and our dogs love them. Our last two treat purchases have included over baked and burnt treats. Not all but many have burnt/blackened edges. Not sure what is going on with quality control but I sure hope they fix the issues. If this is the new normal, we won't be buying them anymore.

I switched to these dog treats since they come in a sealed internal bag. I started to find too many bugs in the box or paper contained type treats. I also like that there are very few ingredients in these. However, if you give your dog too many, they will get the runs. This doesn't make the treat bad, believe me this happens in people too that consume too many "gluten free" goods. I know, I can't have gluten so experience the effects often of gluten free products. It's just too bad these treats went from $9.98 to $14.98 in a year and a halfs time. With 5 dogs I used to buy several times a month. Now I get them once a month and they get less of them, 1 treat per 3 dogs.

My yorkies will eat these, but they don't seem to like them as much as other snacks. The price is good and you get a good amount. These have lasted a long time, mostly bc my dogs aren't the biggest fans and I've already bought other snacks for them. I doubt very much I'll be buying these again. Nothing wrong with them, my dogs just like other snacks more.

I thought these sounded good re: ingredients, but my dog does NOT like them! Funny thing, one of my neighbors purchased for their dog and their dog doesn't like them, either. Neither dog is very picky. Purchased quite a while back and we are still working on the first of two bags inside the box. I should have returned them after the first bone or two. Waste of $$$. I may donate the rest to the local rescue.

We have used these treats for years and my furry friends LOVE them. I love that they are only made with 5 ingredients, that they are fairly low fat...and the best thing is that they are made in Washington State...in Monroe. USA sourced and processed. I give it 50 stars!

Got these as a treat for our dogs, we have a Siberian Husky, Yorkie and Cockapoo. They usually go right for a Biscuit, but they want nothing to do with these grain free peanut butter treats. They seem healthy enough, only a few natural ingredients. Unfortunately turned out to be a waste of money. I live too far away to return for a refund.

My dogs all love these "cookies." Will they ever be available in stores again? These were one of the VERY FEW that my one dog with multiple allergies is able to eat, and now I can't seem to find them in any stores. I have looked in 6 locations. Please bring them back!

Our treats are crushed/broken inside perfect packaging, so it's definitely a quality control issue. I will post later if my dogs actually like them, but beware you may end up with pieces, not treat size. There's not a whole "treat" in the inside package (there's 2 packages inside box and both are in pieces)

My dog LOVES these treats! He will eat just about anything, but he definitely goes a lot more crazy for these than anything else we have bought him. Why have they not been available? I am about out, and I would hate to have to find something else that is so healthy and my dog still loves!

I started added generic creamy peanut butter in between the bones making peanut butter 🥪 sandwiches. She's over 100 lbs. So I fill the bottom of a Sam's Club Rotisserie Chicken tray and she loves them! Her favorite now. Those black plastic Rotisserie chicken trays are also what I use for her Kibble. She is a Mastiff.. and like many purebreds, she has had her fair share of health problems including being highly allergic to grains (except rice). She had liquid diarrhea nonstop for the first 5 years of her life. I took her to do many vets who told me nothing and cost me over $3,000 over those 5 years. I finally figured it out myself and put her on Purina Pro Plan Chicken & Rice. I also buy Sam's boneless skinless chicken breasts.. boil them with tons of extra water and run them through the blade side up of a food processor and place them in covered nonfat yogurt containers in the freezer. I only add a small handful along with a couple of tablespoons of canned green beans mixed in with the kibble. If she gets too bored, I use canned salmon about one rounded tablespoon in place of or combined with the chicken. Those black Rotisserie chicken bottoms last for months and don't need soap to clean. I just run rhem under the faucet on high spray and let them drip dry. I hope some of you can use this information. It saved my dog and I don't even have to clean up her poop because I live on a street with wildlife and they eat it. Yuck! But Yay!