I had previously bought the Member's Mark chocolate shakes in the cardboard material and they were good. These I bought by accident and thought they were packaged in cardboard material however these were in plastic bottles. Not only are they difficult to open the shake have a plastic after taste that is hard to ignore.

like some others have said terrible smell that is hard to get past and white chunks in the bottom even after shaking really well. dumped it in the sink when i got a chunk of something in my mouth..yuck abd gross. WASTE OF MONEY cause not sure i can get past the smell, the chunks and odd aftertaste.. Nurri is Way better!!

Holy cow,I usually only buy Fairlife Chocolate protein drinks. I have tried plenty of different brand shakes,I really don't like the boxed members mark protein drinks, but this ultra filtered tasted great and is affordable! Will definitely buy it again prolly pour it into my protein cereal as well!

If you're second guessing getting this one bc it seems to good to be true, get it! I've been on this health journey since September trying to do better with my protein intake especially since I'm not a big breakfast person, but I'm also a nurse and long hrs at the hospital I have to eat earlier. This is a great way to get my protein in, the taste is delicious, the after taste is not chalky at all! Definitely need to drink these cold, the colder the better. This is my official one and already ordering my next batch!

I had high hopes of this dupe after reading reviews but No Sir! Yes it has the macros I am looking for. I really tried to give it a chance but I couldnt get past the smell or chemical aftertaste. I mean, it reminded me of smells on a dairy farm and i couldnt do it. I really wanted to find a dupe, but this is not it.

These are a great tasting protein drink that's not chalky and is quick.

I am lactose intolerant, and these are lactose free and they have a fantastic vanilla taste

They tasted awful. They smell bad and taste bad.

Great protein shake love the taste

Very soft and comfortable shirt. I would buy again.