I bought this and was expecting it to be similar to the fairlife protein shakes because they’re both ultra filtered, but this one blew fairlife out of the water. It is creamy and sweet, like a melted milkshake and the vanilla taste is powerful but not artificial or weird. Definitely recommend!

As protein shakes, they're fine. What's annoying is the absurd level of tamper resistance in the packaging. These things come in their own sturdy box. No one's getting in there without you noticing. Then, each bottle's cap is held on with shrink wrap. THEN you have to take the cap off and remove a foil safety seal in order to finally reach the shake itself. Crazy, crazy overkill. Unless the goal is to burn maximum calories trying to get at the product I guess?

The price was good and I thought it would be like Fairlife. Unfortunately, it is not like Fairlife. It does taste like milk, however, it also has a boiled egg smell. Each time you take a sip, you get hit with that smell. I gave this two stars because it was low in carbs and high in protein. My son, who is an athlete, powered through and drank them so the product did not go to waste.

I bought 4 of these from the refrigerated section at the cafe. Was told they were very good and was glad to have the option to buy them in small quantities to try it for myself. Three have had an awful eggy smell, with the third one being really stinky. I'm scared to even open the fourth. Not sure if this is what the product is like or if something was really wrong with this batch, but I'm too grossed out now to try again. I typically love Members Mark quality and was glad to see they are making these typically expensive shakes at a more affordable price but….

Pretty impressed with this. It definitely compares to the Vanilla fair life that is not available anymore and at a really good price. I like that it does not contain Carrageenan like so many others do. The only annoying thing is the fact it is sealed on the outside of the bottle and also on the cap, I feel like it should be one or the other not both.

These are pretty decent, but the flavor is a bit eggy, as others have mentioned. I wasn't sure what that meant until I had one, but these taste like an egg-based custard rather than just milk with vanilla. Again, it's not a bad flavor if you expect it, but it could be off-putting for some.

Obviously this is the Members Mark's take on fairlife ultra filtered protein %26 the texture is smooth without any clumps. But the vanilla flavor is...off. A bit more like premier protein than the melted ice cream like flavor of fairlife. Decent for the price but not an unrecognizable dupe. The bottles feel like they use a lot more plastic than necessary

Tastes ok, but smells kinda like spoiled milk/eggs. I haven't gotten a stomach ache from drinking them at least. probably won't buy them again right now. maybe try again in several months and see if I got a bad batch? Probably need better quality control. Another review from this time said the same thing...

The Member's Mark Ultra Filtered Milk Shake in Vanilla is truly a standout product that exceeded all my expectations. The vanilla flavor is rich, smooth, and perfectly balanced. It has a creamy texture. Overall, product combines convenience, flavor, and nutrition. I highly recommend it to anyone who enjoys vanilla and wants a versatile, high-quality beverage.

I really like these. They have a very nice vanilla flavor. I keep them in the refrigerator and when I get up in the morning, put one in the freezer for about 30 minutes. This makes them more like a "milk shake". I hope they change the chocolate flavor to this formulation, because they could be improved. If you like vanilla, I think you'd like these (I'm super picky.)