Obviously this is the Members Mark's take on fairlife ultra filtered protein %26 the texture is smooth without any clumps. But the vanilla flavor is...off. A bit more like premier protein than the melted ice cream like flavor of fairlife. Decent for the price but not an unrecognizable dupe. The bottles feel like they use a lot more plastic than necessary

This protein shake is amazing but I need it in CHOCOLATE flavor like Fairlife! Also please fix the packaging, why is there an aluminum seal under the cap? No other protein shakes have this and it is hard to break the plastic to get the cap off with my arthritis.

I wanted to love this because it quite a bit cheaper than the Nurri brand but there were a few cons I cannot get passed. I've had it happen twice where I find little clumps at the bottom and swallowing these were gross. Alongside to that, there's a film that formed at the rim of the bottle that got stuck to my lips and grossed me out too.

This vanilla protein shake is absolutely amazing! It's super creamy with a smooth texture and has a rich, yummy vanilla flavor that doesn't taste chalky like some other shakes. It feels like a treat while still giving me the protein boost I need. Highly recommend!

Pretty impressed with this. It definitely compares to the Vanilla fair life that is not available anymore and at a really good price. I like that it does not contain Carrageenan like so many others do. The only annoying thing is the fact it is sealed on the outside of the bottle and also on the cap, I feel like it should be one or the other not both.

Sam's Club understood the assignment!👏 After not being able to purchase the vanilla Fairlife shakes for over 2 years, Sam's Club said, let's dupe it. It isnt an exact dupe but it is very close. Definitely a 9/10 as far as taste goes and a 10/10 in terms of price! Now the real trick will be, keeping enough stock!

I bought 4 of these from the refrigerated section at the cafe. Was told they were very good and was glad to have the option to buy them in small quantities to try it for myself. Three have had an awful eggy smell, with the third one being really stinky. I'm scared to even open the fourth. Not sure if this is what the product is like or if something was really wrong with this batch, but I'm too grossed out now to try again. I typically love Members Mark quality and was glad to see they are making these typically expensive shakes at a more affordable price but….

Shake is great, tastes good and has good macros. My only complaint is, I don't think whoever made this actually opened this before. Why in the world would they make you rip a small piece of plastic off the top open the bottle and then have to rip another piece of foil off the cap?!? Now I can have all of these little pieces of plastic and trash all over the place. A similar competitor uses an aluminum can which is great, no plastic, recyclable, and way easier to open.

This is not a comparable dupe to the Fairlife protein drinks. Even though the ingredients are almost identical, the flavor is not even close and tastes off. Not sure if we just received a bad batch as there are many positive reviews, but we definitely won't be purchasing again. This item can't be returned so I'll be donating the extra case and unopened bottles to a food pantry.

These are pretty decent, but the flavor is a bit eggy, as others have mentioned. I wasn't sure what that meant until I had one, but these taste like an egg-based custard rather than just milk with vanilla. Again, it's not a bad flavor if you expect it, but it could be off-putting for some.