I was very excited to try these shakes. My wife and I are big Fairlife fans and were disappointed how the other 30 gram shake flavors were except chocolate, were discontinued. These shakes have very similar nutritional facts to Fairlife, but when it comes to taste its not close. These shakes taste good when you are drinking them, but the aftertaste is funky. They also have a weird smell from the bottle too. If you want a low cost, high protein option this is a great option, however you won't enjoy the crisp sweet taste of a Fairlife.

Packaging - The top has a wrap seal a foil seal under cap, nice but annoying considering it was in a sealed case. The lid to drink out of is a weird shape (very thick), don't like mouth feel. Texture - not as thick as fairlife but not as thin as oikos. Flavor - mild vanilla, slight strange (artificial?) aftertaste, leaves a filmy feel in mouth. Would not buy again. Disappointed. Macros are nice, better price than others. Was hoping could be a new drink.

Sam's Club understood the assignment!👏 After not being able to purchase the vanilla Fairlife shakes for over 2 years, Sam's Club said, let's dupe it. It isnt an exact dupe but it is very close. Definitely a 9/10 as far as taste goes and a 10/10 in terms of price! Now the real trick will be, keeping enough stock!

Pretty impressed with this. It definitely compares to the Vanilla fair life that is not available anymore and at a really good price. I like that it does not contain Carrageenan like so many others do. The only annoying thing is the fact it is sealed on the outside of the bottle and also on the cap, I feel like it should be one or the other not both.

Good vanilla taste, no artificial or after taste for me. Good value compare to other brands. A lot of ingredients but overall I will buy again and do recommend. Gave it a 4 because of the ingredients. I've been looking for a protein shake with natural ingredients only but all are expensive and taste horrible.

Gives off a weird plastic taste. Hoped pouring into a cup would lessen that effect but it did not. The off-putting taste still comes through mixed with coffee/espresso. Not as sweet as Nurri, which I was looking forward to since adding coffee flavorings makes some shakes too sweet. Was really hoping this would be closer to Fairlife but definitely not.

Impossible to open. First u have to get a knife to cut off the shrink wrap around the lid. Then after u cut off the shrink wrap, u twist the cap off to find a foil piece covering the opening. The foil doesn't just peel off either. So now go get ur knife again to stab and poke the foil covering and peel off the remaining foil shards, try not to cut urself on the foil edges...then u can drink. Ridiculous. Who at Sam's failed to realize people drink protein shakes on the go, in a hurry...u can't with these.

Absolutely love this product! The Member's Mark Unfiltered Vanilla Milkshake has an amazing, rich flavor that tastes just like real vanilla ice cream. It's smooth, creamy, and has no chalky or artificial aftertaste like many other protein or milkshake drinks. It's perfect as a quick breakfast, post-workout treat, or even a healthy dessert substitute. I'm genuinely impressed with the quality and taste — it feels like a real milkshake, not something out of a bottle. I really hope they come out with more flavors soon, because this one is a winner!

Very tasty. Not a fake vanilla taste. Do not taste like a protein shake, just vanilla milk.

They were very good. No nasty after taste. I like to mix with my coffee in the morning 🥰🥰🥰