I honestly thought it was horrible. I love protein shakes to supplement my hunger, as I work 12 hour shifts over night. I have tried many protein shakes and this is in my top that I'll never buy again. I also shake well and there are chunks still. Throwing out. I'm not sure how there are so many positive reviews for this.

I wanted to love the protein shakes. I really did. Their flavor is actually really good; pretty similar to the Fairlife Vanilla. However, the actual smell of the protein shake in the bottle smells like spoiled milk. I thought it was just the fact that maybe the foil safety tab had gotten some protein shake on there and it has spoiled. But it is literally EVERY SINGLE SHAKE that has this same funky smell. I tried pouring it into a cup which, helps a little, but the smell is still there. I can't drink them because the smell is so off-putting that it makes me feel like I am drinking spoiled milk. Members Mark needs to fix this problem ASAP because these shakes are a great price and they taste good if it weren't for the smell. I will say that the longer you have the shakes, the more they start to taste like they smell, which is even more unappetizing.

these were just alright. I did like the creamy melted vanilla milkshake taste but literally the smell of these were so strong. And not in a good way. They honestly smelled like ham... It was very off putting. Once I mixed it with other powders or blended with fruits it wasn't as noticeable but straight out of the bottle was not my go to.

Definitely not the worst tasting protein drink I've ever had, and the texture is good, with no gritty/graininess or slimy feeling you sometimes get with other protein drinks. However, I couldn't help but notice a very strong plastic-like taste to these drinks, in both flavors offered (vanilla and strawberry). It was really off-putting, and it was even noticeable when I used the vanilla flavor in my morning coffee. I won't be buying these again for this reason alone. If Sam's Club fixed this plastic taste, I would happily try them again.

My new choice of premade shake. I used to be big on the fair life shakes but the price keeps increasing and the quality was tanking. $18 for a 12 pack is a whole lot better than $26 for a 12 pack. The taste is great too and they're creamy. Just wish they had a chocolate flavor.

Ok so, I never leave reviews but love this protein shake so much I felt like I had to. This is my new favorite, most vanilla flavors claim to taste like a vanilla milkshake but this one really does. Will keep buying these, I hope they never discontinue them. Love the strawberry flavor too!

Second time I've purchased the MM product comparable to Fairlife's product. Great vanilla taste and no aftertaste. But second purchase the slimy pieces nearly made me gag and same problem 3 consecutive bottles.Im guessing that heat has caused proteins to congeal as shaking before opening doesn't change the outcome. I'll try a bottle from another pack. If there's a problem they're going back

30g of protein with only 150 calories is a positive (80% protein), but the aftertaste was unpleasant. I had to take bites of banana between sips to make it tolerable. I saw a lot of positive reviews in regards to the taste and that made me hopeful. Seeing people saying that it tastes like ice cream makes me think that the box I got was a bad batch or something. It tasted nothing like ice cream to me. I feel cheated by my experience.

I really like this shake.. but I buy protein shakes for when I am on the go, so usually they are chugged in the car between drop off, pickup, job sites, etc. The process to get it open is maddening compared to other similar protein shakes. This has an exterior seal to tear off, a lid, and an interior seal to peel off. Compare this to others that are just a pop-top can or you just open a well-sealed bottle... when you're driving, you just need to get it open safely and quickly!

I was hopeful with all the positive reviews. Very let down, weird smell and after taste. They were drinkable, but there's something off tasting about it. I did also shake really well and there were some that the chunks still were floating around. I finished the case but definitely not a fan.