I was hopeful with all the positive reviews. Very let down, weird smell and after taste. They were drinkable, but there's something off tasting about it. I did also shake really well and there were some that the chunks still were floating around. I finished the case but definitely not a fan.

i like the product it tastes good. but the packing is a pain. the box is over glued and hard to open. the bottles are fully wrapped and a pain to tear into, then after you open the lid there is another seal. should take some tips from Fairlife's packaging they use the same bottles.

Ok so, I never leave reviews but love this protein shake so much I felt like I had to. This is my new favorite, most vanilla flavors claim to taste like a vanilla milkshake but this one really does. Will keep buying these, I hope they never discontinue them. Love the strawberry flavor too!

I thought this would be a great alternative to Fairlife, and at a better price. The packaging is too many layers of plastic. When you remove the foil seal there are still some bits on the bottle. It makes me worry about ingesting too many micro plastics. Also, it doesn't have the same vitamins and minerals as Fairlife. And it's only available in vanilla.

I was excited to give this a try in both the strawberry and vanilla varieties. My initial taste with both exceeded my expectations. The flavors to both were really good and rivaled the tastes of the Nurri ultra filtered protein milk shakes. My only issue with the Members Mark varieties was that there were annoying lumps as you nearly finish the bottle, which felt gross when detected. I even attempted to vigorously shake each bottle prior to consumption, but this did not fix the issue, and I have not purchased since.

I'm always skeptical of these drinks having odd notes and tastes, especially since I typically associate Member's Mark brand as cheap knock off versions of popular brands, but they nailed it with this one - tastes just like a vanilla milk shake! Personally, I prefer to refrigerate them and drink them cold rather than room temp. Will definitely continue buying these!

The flavor of the shakes is delicious…if you can get to it. Removing the wrapper is difficult, removing the lid is difficult, and then you're met with a foil seal which is, you guessed it, difficult to remove. I am currently recovering from cervical fusion and am in a neck brace so I am having to drink these through a straw. It's disgusting. No matter how hard it is shaken or how many different directions it is shaken, there are *always* chunks at the bottom. Normally, you wouldn't notice this. I am assuming that is the protein. So, if it is not mixing well, you may not be getting the full amount of protein—just something to keep in mind. I thought they were great before my surgery…until I had to drink them through a straw.

This Member's Mark Ultra-Filtered Vanilla Milk Shake is amazing! It actually tastes good straight up, but I use it almost daily as the base in my protein coffee! I actually think it's better than the Nurri or Fairlife shakes. Very excited to see the new strawberry flavor! Hoping a chocolate, caramel or mocha flavor might be forthcoming…

On the fence about this. Good taste and not super heavy feeling. Mixes great with coffee to make a protein packed iced coffee BUT nearly all of my bottles I purchased around 4/26 of this year (4 days ago) have chunks in them.. I had to strain them all out into a big jug because I am huge on textures. Again the taste is fine, I don't think they are ‘bad' as in expired but if you have a weak stomach, idk if I would risk it. Expiration date is January 2027 btw

The taste is fine, but there is a weird smell like cheese, or off cream. I could not get past that smell while drinking it, it was pretty disgusting. A shame as otherwise the taste was ok. I'll be going back to Fairlife Core Power even though they're more expensive, they're actually nice.