This product is really good the shake itself, however, the packaging totally sucks. First, you have to take the plastic off the outside, then peel off a foil cap underneath the actual cap, and then the edge of the bottle where you drink from is sharp. A real bummer the packaging ruined these for us.

This is the worst protein shake I have ever had. I usually but Premier (powder or premade), but I tried it because of the price. BIG MISTAKE! When I opened it, I noticed a very unppealing oder , I thought it was spoiled. I had my wife take a sip and she said it was most likely the container and also a cheap vanilla flavoring. She said it was sub par. There is no accounting for taste, but I will not be buyIng it again no matter what the price.

i like the product it tastes good. but the packing is a pain. the box is over glued and hard to open. the bottles are fully wrapped and a pain to tear into, then after you open the lid there is another seal. should take some tips from Fairlife's packaging they use the same bottles.

I thought this would be a great alternative to Fairlife, and at a better price. The packaging is too many layers of plastic. When you remove the foil seal there are still some bits on the bottle. It makes me worry about ingesting too many micro plastics. Also, it doesn't have the same vitamins and minerals as Fairlife. And it's only available in vanilla.

Love the shake. Vanilla tastes good, maybe has a hint of tapioca-ish flavor. Only negative is it's definitely a two-handed job getting into the shake since you have to peel off the outer wrapper and then the foil top under the lid. So, of it's a grab and go shake

This Member's Mark Ultra-Filtered Vanilla Milk Shake is amazing! It actually tastes good straight up, but I use it almost daily as the base in my protein coffee! I actually think it's better than the Nurri or Fairlife shakes. Very excited to see the new strawberry flavor! Hoping a chocolate, caramel or mocha flavor might be forthcoming…

Taste is average, which I can deal with. What's awful about these is the random glob at the bottom, providing the visceral response you'd get if you swallowed a hunk of mucus that didn't originally belong to you. Yes I shake them up very well, but about every third bottle has this unwelcome surprise. The other issue I have is the container itself, thick plastic. I'll go back to the MM shakes with no globs and mostly cardboard containers.

Definitely has a slight smell to it. it taste like 2% vanilla milk. not terrible, it's actually tolerable on its own. it doesn't have a funny after taste. but the smell throws off the rating. if you are drinking it plain soild 3 stars . but i mix it with instant coffee and a little mocha syrup and its easily 5 stars.. I've tried other vanilla protein shakes with instant coffee and the after taste is terrible.. this one is fantastic!!!

Well Sam's really missed the Mark on this one! The bottle packaging is a real nightmare!! First, you have to struggle to get the shrink wrap off the top, and the plastic does not tear well. Second, you have to remove the screw-on cap (which should really be all you would have to do like on Fairlife). Third, you have to peel off an aluminum cover that does not come off easily. Why didn't they just use the standard "crack-open" screw on lid like Fairlife. The flavor and texture of the drink, once you work your way down to it, is very good! Unfortunately, they ruined it with the very difficult to open bottle. The drink is obviously made to copy the Fairlife protein drinks using ultra filtered lactose free milk. It actually tastes a lot better than Fairlife, but I don't know if I'm willing to suffer thru the packaging again. This would have been a 5-star review if not for the bottle packaging. Sad!!!

The flavor of the shakes is delicious…if you can get to it. Removing the wrapper is difficult, removing the lid is difficult, and then you're met with a foil seal which is, you guessed it, difficult to remove. I am currently recovering from cervical fusion and am in a neck brace so I am having to drink these through a straw. It's disgusting. No matter how hard it is shaken or how many different directions it is shaken, there are *always* chunks at the bottom. Normally, you wouldn't notice this. I am assuming that is the protein. So, if it is not mixing well, you may not be getting the full amount of protein—just something to keep in mind. I thought they were great before my surgery…until I had to drink them through a straw.