First off, I loved how it was very sealed both on the outside and on the inside. The second thing I noticed is that I wasn't as sweet as I thought it would be, so that was a plus for me. I liked that it has a bit of a vanilla ice cream taste, however, it had an eggnog smell when I first opened the bottle which was a bit of a throw off to me. Aside, that it is a very decent low calorie milkshake. A plus is that my kids liked it.

Great new shake! It's very smooth tasting and thin. It's not thick and goopy like some shakes. It also doesn't have that protein aftertaste that I hate so much! I have enjoyed it as a coffee creamer, a mid day snack and I like to put instant coffee into the bottle, shake up and drink. It's delicious that way!

I was really surprised of how delicious this product tasted. It was really good and very flavorful. It filled me up and kept me full throughout the day. Very tasty flavor and didn't leave a nasty aftertaste like other products do. I'd recommend to anyone.

These taste great and there is a good variety of tasty flavors. I have been using these for meal replacement for weight loss and they are great because of the high protein and low calories. I find them very filling as well. I definitely will be buying more. This is one of my favorite protein shakes

The members mark ultra filtered milkshake tasted very good. It actually tasted like a milkshake and didn't have any after taste at all like some drinks do. It was creamy and I would definitely recommend it for anyone wanting to get some extra protein in their diet.

The Member's Mark Vanilla Ultrafiltered Protein Shake is an impressive option for anyone looking for a convenient, high-quality protein beverage that does not sacrifice flavor. From the first sip, the vanilla taste stands out as smooth, clean, and well-balanced. The flavor is rich and familiar, closely matching that of well-known name-brand competitors, yet it manages to feel refined rather than artificial. One of the most notable strengths of this shake is its sweetness level. It is perfectly sweet without crossing into the overly sugary territory that many ready-to-drink protein shakes fall into. The vanilla flavor comes through clearly and consistently, making it enjoyable to drink on its own without the need to dilute or mix it with anything else. This balance makes it suitable both as a quick post-workout recovery drink and as a convenient meal supplement during a busy day. The texture is another strong point. The shake is smooth and easy to drink, without the chalky or gritty mouthfeel that can detract from similar products. Portion size is appropriate, providing enough volume to be satisfying without feeling heavy or excessive. It fits well into a daily routine, whether consumed at breakfast, after exercise, or as a mid-day protein boost. Overall, this vanilla ultrafiltered protein shake delivers excellent flavor, proper sweetness, and a satisfying size. It performs on par with name-brand competitors while offering a very enjoyable drinking experience, making it a reliable and appealing choice.

Tried the member's mark vanilla protein milkshake, it's not bad. I'm more of a fan of the Fairlife brand and love that Sam's Club carries them but this is another lower price option. There is a bit of plastic-y taste but better tasting IMO than Premier brand. I like that it has low sugar. The consistency is very liquid (no carageenan) and i tried to freeze it a bit to try in a smoothie and it doesn't freeze. Mixed it with strong coffee and it made a decent vanilla iced latte. Definitely worth a try and with the increasing cost of the fair life in premier shakes, this is a worthwhile option to consider.

My daughter and I tried these, and we both were super pleased with these shakes. We felt these were very comparable with the Fair life brand products. The amount of calories and protein make for a good snack or even a breakfast. My daughter said it tasted like a vanilla milkshake.

The vanilla milk shake doesn't disappoint. It is smooth tasting and one of the best shakes I have tasted that is low carb. It is filling with 30g of protein. It's low in sugar and has 150 calories. I had it mid morning so it kept me full till lunch. I also didn't get any stomach upset. I would def recommend it.

I tried the Member's Mark Ultra-Filtered Milk Shake, Vanilla for the first time as a quick breakfast option on a busy weekday morning. I drank it at home before heading out the door, and I've since kept a few in the fridge for afternoons when I want something filling but easy. It's also been convenient to grab after light workouts when I don't feel like making a full meal. The vanilla flavor is smooth and creamy without tasting overly sweet or artificial. I like that it has a thicker texture than regular milk, which makes it feel more like a treat while still being practical. The ultra-filtered milk makes it feel more satisfying, and it kept me full longer than I expected. Likes: Smooth vanilla flavor, creamy texture, convenient single-serve bottle, and filling enough for a snack or light meal. Dislikes: Best served very cold, and I wish there were more flavor options available. Overall, this milk shake is a convenient and tasty option for busy mornings, quick snacks, or post-workout recovery. It's a solid choice when you want something simple, satisfying, and easy to enjoy anywhere.