This shake was really good and good source of protein. I drank one cold i used one to add to my coffee as a milk replacement. The flavor is sweet but not over powering to the coffee. Definitely a must.

It was ok, really just tasted like vanilla milk and didn’t keep me satiated like I expected. I would buy this again if Fairlife wasn’t available, but I guess it makes a pretty good second choice. Might be good as a smoothie base.

I didn't find it tastes particularly like a milkshake, but it was still good. The flavor is light and creamy. I imagine if I added ice and blended it, it just might taste more like a milkshake.

This is a creamy protein shake with good vanilla flavor. It was perfect for after a workout. We drank them right out of the bottle. My teenager also liked the flavor better than any other protein shakes we have tried.

These are delicious! I struggle to get enough protein into my diet and this makes it so much easier. These taste like homemade vanilla ice cream and don't have an after taste like most protein drinks. These are just as good as Fairlife shakes!

This protein shake was so good, not too sweet and doesn't take chalky. The thickness was perfect, I had it right out the bottle. I would use this to replace a meal or if I wanted to get in more protein.

Smells just like melted vanilla ice cream. Vanilla taste is pleasant and doesn't have a funny after taste. Isn't a strong vanilla taste and doesn't coat your mouth like whole milk, more like skim milk. Would be really good on cereal.

This members mark ultra filtered milkshake was good. I am not a big fan of vanilla but the shake was sweet and had a good texture. It wasn't overly protein rich flavored. Some can be powder tasting or have after taste. This did not.

January 23rd 2026 tried Members Mark protein drink at home. Really like the consistency and taste of this vanilla flavor drink. It wasn’t think or powdery tasting. The taste was better than the smell. I would recommend.

Very impressed with the Iltra-Filtered Milk protein shake!!! Absolutely delicious and smooth. The flavor was really good without being overly sweet! Not to mention having 30 grams of protein is a win win!!