Milk is milk, this brand is always good. Inner seal is often difficult to remove unless you have a vise-grip finger strength. But a paring knife can bypass that easily enough. Bottom of carton cut off at various heights can be a pet food dish, toilet brush holder, or many things if you are a DIYer

It tastes a little off. I normally purchase the Organic Horizon whole milk or the Kirkland Organic whole milk. I will not purchase again this members mark milk. If Memebers Mark decides to sell an organic option only then will I purchase a similar product.

Noticed nothing different about the milk really. Milk is milk, I suppose. However, the container is horrible. My kids can pour from a regular milk jug but ALWAYS manage to spill when I buy this one. I figured out how to manage it and have tried to teach them you just have to change your pouring technique, but it’s a little silly to even have to do that, don’t you think? I’ve truly tried to just deal with it but I can’t. I usually avoid buying milk from Sam’s because of the container. Any money you saved due to the good price is lost when you spill the milk. Just not worth the frustration.

I mainly buy milk to froth with my morning coffee. Usually milk is good even shortly after the expiration date. I still had almost a week before the expiration date a it got smelly and clumpy beforehand and had to dump most of the gallon down the drain. I'm a Sam's Club fan, but have to stick with Aldi's on this one.

Not all milk is equal. I don't drink milk by the glass but my husband and grand dau devour it. They can tell when I buy some of the off brands in a pinch. They say that the flavor is definitely different and one brand is like water. Both of them enjoy this milk and I try to keep it on hand with my limited fridge space. It's also a good value.

Even when stored on the top shelf, all the way in the back of our fridge, this milk seems to always start to sour about 3 days before the best by/expired date. Perhaps it's just a handling and temp holding issue that we ran into as a one off, but it's happened at least 2 times and that's enough for us to prefer milk from other grocery stores.

For whatever reason the Whole Milk from local grocery stores spoiled prior to expiration date. This happened so many times, that we checked our refrigerator to make sure it was operating properly. I thought I would give Members Mark Whole Milk a try and it is fantastic. I refuse to buy any other brand. It is fresh, creamy and does not spoil prior to the expiration.

It is milk. My issue is it usually cost more than my regular little store by 5 to 10 cents, and the jugs are just a bit taller. For the home fridge, this is fine, but for my portable electric cooler in the car, it means the lid will not close. I measured my normal milk jugs before buying the cooler, and they fit fine. But these do not. I have to lay the jugs down, which, because if the inner seal, has been fine with NO leakage. But I wouldn’t want to go on a long bumpy road with them that way.

This review is a result of the jug the milk comes in, not the milk itself. This design of this container must fill a need somewhere other than the end user pouring the milk out of the container because it is the least user-friendly container I have ever seen. It is too tall to fit in multiple areas of the refrigerator, is extremely cumbersome ergonomically and has a ridge on the inside of the handle which cuts into your fingers as you pour out the contents. It's akin to taking a round wheel and making it square for stability!

I know everyone has their opinions but i really hate the gallon jug this milk comes in. Other than that, i normally dont buy this milk as the milk usually goes bad before the date. It tastes good, which is why i buy it in a pinch. Walmart brand is cheaper and lasts longer.