Member's Mark Vitamin D Whole Milk is exactly what whole milk should be—rich, creamy, and full‑flavored. The texture is smooth without feeling heavy, and it works beautifully for everything from cereal and baking to making a really good cup of coffee. The gallon size is a great value, and it stays fresh in the fridge with no off taste. If you like classic, full‑fat milk that tastes clean and wholesome, this one is a dependable pick.

Weird shape for a container. Makes first pouring a bit of a challenge. Often has piece of plastic left in handle hole. But now the really good part -- even though it cost more than Aldi's milk, over the last 6 months of buying it, the milk stays good and usable for 3 to 4 weeks past the expiration date on the jug. Passes the sniff and taste test and no curds forming. Don't know what magic they're using, but keep it up guys!!

This is the best milk out there. It tastes great and doesn't spoil early. It's usually good for several days after the expiration date. And the price is nice.

This is the only size of milk that stands a chance of lasting more than two days in my refrigerator, thanks to my son. I wish that lactose free milk in this size was available.

The only reason it's not 5 stars is because I really don't care for the bottle shape! It's hard to unscrew the cap because it's indented, and I always end up spilling milk. I don't understand why it's shaped like that but it's a pain in the rear and I don't really like purchasing it from Sam's because of that.

The bottle design is really bad, one wrong move with the bottle cap and you can hurt your finger bad. Milk taste like milk. Nothing to write home about. I buy it as last resort if I run out of milk and I happen to go to Sam's but I prefer the one from Walmart in the regular jug.

I can't open this container. The milk is great, but, if I can't open it, what's the point? Then I googled Sam's milk container and there are literal groups on social media complaining too! Sam's stop being tone deaf! Change the container! It's impossible to open!

Ok I’m picky about milk, and this one the taste was a little off, like not fresh. I’m sure it was fine to drink, because the expiration was over a week away, but I only drank a couple of glasses and threw the rest out. Probably will not buy milk from here again.

Cost of milk was a dollar more than at the Walmart stores

This milk spoiled well before its expiration date. It was stored in a very cold refrigerator. I was very disappointed, as we had to throw away over a half gallon.