This is the best milk out there. It tastes great and doesn't spoil early. It's usually good for several days after the expiration date. And the price is nice.

I love the milk, I love the container shape, but the piece you have to pull off under the cap is nothing short of impossible to get off. The plastic piece you grab and pull just tears off the rest of it. I always have to cut it with a knife and then peel it off. They need to fix this!

We purchase Vitamin D whole milk for the vitamins that it provides. I do not care for the watered-down skim milk at all. It has a good shelf life and is quite tasty. The only reason I gave it four stars instead of five is that it is a little hard to pick up and pour. It seems heavier than other brands with the way that the handle is positioned on the jug.

Even when stored on the top shelf, all the way in the back of our fridge, this milk seems to always start to sour about 3 days before the best by/expired date. Perhaps it's just a handling and temp holding issue that we ran into as a one off, but it's happened at least 2 times and that's enough for us to prefer milk from other grocery stores.

The trick is to figure out how to keep it from going sour before the Expiration date on the jug.

Not sure I'm crazy about the new jug design! The milk is awesome

When I have to get a knife to remove seal under the cap it’s quite apparent that the customer is not in mind when you approve this product. When this new container came out a couple of years ago, I told my wife not to buy just because of the seal was almost impossible to remove without cutting with a knife. Just think of the dangers involved with a sharp knife and a hand or finger getting cut.

These jugs are a horrible design. I typically avoid buying milk at Sam's club because these are the only containers used and they are ridiculous. You can not pour the milk without it leaking all over the counter. First time you open it is the worst. There is no way to pour this without making a mess. I literally buy my milk somewhere else because of the container.

Curbside service- When I buy my milk, I want the Best Used by Date info printed on the carton. There was no indication, as a result I had to go into the store to exchange it. A woman at the courtesy counter had the nerve to tell me she has bought Sam’s milk without dates on it! I also returned the fresh Spinach salad, as the date was expiring in 2 days. Curbside service customers don’t deserve these substandard items!

Milk soured before best use by date