I love French Onion soup and this didn't disappoint. Taste and texture were on point. The croutons and cheese were portioned well. Stove top heating took just a couple minutes. The price per serving was very affordable. My wife was also a big fan. No complaints whatsoever!

One packet of soup was fine, but second packet soup was much darker than the other packet and contained pieces of fat. When poured into pot for heating the darker packet contained dark black pieces of unknown substance. Since I had emptied the clear packet first and then added the darker packet, I had to throw the soup away. Very poor inspection of the item and could have caused my family a grave illness. So unlike Members Mark products. Since the packaging obscured the contents, the bags of soup were undetectable until opening.

This soup was easy to prepare and came with great add ons. The actually soup was very nasty. It didn’t taste like onions or beef broth. All we could taste was vinegar. Tried adding more broth to lessen the vinegar taste but it was too terrible to eat.

Very tart, sour like vinegar. I was assuming that the kit would come with soup base not actual onion soup, believing that I would be the one to chop and cook onions before adding. but it's this broth - almost like they were supposed to add wine, but added vinegar instead. I cannot recommend this because it isn't even close to French onion soup.

Thin, way too SWEET tasting, very little flavor complexity, besides sweet, pepper, and brandy. I will never buy this again due to the poor quality, high carbohydrates, 21 grams per serving, and needless sugar. Sam's needs to do better than waste our resources with this item.

I really love this soup! I think it’s matches up to most diners, not the best I had ever had but cozy and easy to make. Not sure why some reviewers say it has no flavor, but I think it has a great onion flavor along with that sherry hit you expect.

I have always been pleased with Members Mark products. But, this soup was a great disappointment. It did not have the rich beef flavor but was a sour vinegar base with too many large onions. I do not recommend. I will not purchase again. I threw out 2nd package.

Very peppery, like clumps of pepper in your throat. It was quite greasy compared to most restaurant style French onion soups, and there is a very small amount of cheese and salad croutons (??) that go with the soups. Says it serves 4 but it barely served 3 people unless everyone is getting 1/3c of soup. Flavors are off, quantity is off and selection of add-ins is just weird (seriously who puts salad croutons in these? It should be larger pieces of crusted bread)

No idea why so many bad reviews. Maybe different suppliers. We thought the kit was great and have eaten a lot of french onion soups. A lot of nice and tender onions and not super salty. Love that the kit contains (2) 2 serving kits for a total of 4 servings. 2 bags of onion soup, 2 bags croutons and 2 bags of cheese.

This is not French onion soup. 4 servings? Don't think so! This is a watered down version. Skimped on the onions and cheese. Croutons were ok. I caramelized another onion and with a teaspoon of beef bullion and added to the soup. I would not purchase this again