Did not like this

Soup had a very off taste, something is definitely off. I did like the idea of the kit though and the convince.

I was shocked by how badly this smelled and tasted. I think it ruined my silicone serving spoon as I have washed it several times, but the scent is still there. I jokingly told a friend who likes to try different soups that I think this was mislabeled and it was secretly an old fashioned poltice to draw down a fever.

I have purchased 4 different times. The first 2 were good. It was peppery and basically broth and onions but I still enjoyed it. Helped clear the sinuses. These last 2 batches were DISGUSTING. It was a VERY STRONG vinegar taste. When I put in the microwave to cook, it became foamy as well - with the bad batches. I thought the 3rd batch was a fluke since the other 2 were good so I purchased again. The EAXCT same thing happened to the 4th batch. Vinegary and foamy. I will not be buying again. It is too expensive just to dump down the drain for a hit or miss soup.

The sherry vinegar in this soup was overwhelming and made it taste just awful, didn't even taste like French onion soup. We love French onion soup and Members Mark products but this one is a total fail. We threw it away without finishing our bowls.

I’ve always loved the Members Mark refrigerated soups from Sam’s, so I was optimistic about this one. Unfortunately, the French onion soup is the worst soup I’ve ever had. It’s basically onion water with an overwhelming amount of black pepper. This soup was traumatizing.

I tasted a sample of this at the store and thought it was delicious so I purchased two packs, one for me and one for my daughter. I'm not sure if they did something different? But its AWFUL. Very peppery (and I like pepper but this is over done) and very tart. Almost sour like. I couldn't wait to make it... once I did, I couldn't finish it. I seriously thought it was going to make me throw up. My daughter had the same experience. I would buy a cheap can of French Onion soup before I'd buy this again.

French onion soup not that good. I had to throw it away.

There is definitely a badge that has to have spoiled. The soup foamed when heated and was completely soured. It was still within date. I don’t write reuse unless something is that bad. It may have ruined French onion soup for me forever.

Amazing!