[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Zesty paws helped calm my dog during a severe storm and relax her enough that she wasn't shaking or barking from the storm around her. I would highly recommend this product to any one with dogs that have anxiety or reactivity to storms.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I have a crazy two year old puppy and was hoping these calming bites might help her settle a little easier. She adored the treats, super tasty, but didn't really have any effect on her energy level. That's okay for us, just don't buy expecting a miracle!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I'm not sure these really have any calming affects on my dogs. I do know that they gave my dachshund a very upset stomach. It did not affect my doodles, but they're already pretty calm so maybe that's why. Just so so.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My dog really liked this as a treat but I tried it in different occasions like before a walk, before a bath, etc and I didn't noticed any behavior improvements on my dog. He was as barky and nervous as usual. I did have to break them in half for my dog to show interest, otherwise he didn't get it.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I've got 4 dogs who usually use cbd. I tried these zesty paws and find that these treats definitely calmed them all down. Some dogs are picky on treat flavors but will still eat these. Would recommend and would purchase to use again

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I recently received the Zesty Paws Calming Plus Bites for free to try in exchange for my honest review. My dogs love these and take them enthusiastically so no problem there. I love there no artificial flavor or color, and knowing the Calming benefits of melatonin and chamomile that these contain both. That being said, I saw no change in behavior in the short time I've given them to my dogs. Perhaps, especially to get benefit of melatonin, you need to let it build up over time?

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I gave my dog these treats daily and didn't notice any calming effect. He seemed to not really like them or that they get stuck in his mouth because he seemed to need to keep licking in his mouth after eating them. He is a high energy dog so it's possible that these just don't work on him!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Here's the thing, this could be one of those "my dog" things, and not the product itself. We tried them 3 different times. She did not slow her roll, and almost was more anxious. It was strange. I plan to try them again, in a few weeks. She may have just been having an off week. She's typically not super hyper but some weather related noises made her a bit skiddish, and these came in so I figured perfect timing. Using them 3 times I had hoped they'd help her out a bit. Overall mostly the same. With that being said, for another dog these may work just fine and I wouldn't deter someone- in fact I'd want to know if my friends dogs did well with them and if they were chill :) Pros: soft and chewy, not that gross dog treat smell

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My dog loves these treats. I have his full attention when I pull these out, and he gobbles them up. I didn't notice a calming effect on my dog after talking them. NOTE: what I was looking for was a calming effect to the mischievousness he finds himself in. My dog doesn't get anxious during thunderstorms or anything like that. So those may be two different things. I would still recommend trying these.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I have a small dog about 10-12 pounds. I gave 1 soft chew calming bite. My dog is very anxious and gets nervous easily. I noticed this did make her more sleepy, I guess you'd call that calm. My dog loved them, and was able to chew them easily. If your pup has issues chewing they might have a hard time with these.