[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I gave my dog these treats daily and didn't notice any calming effect. He seemed to not really like them or that they get stuck in his mouth because he seemed to need to keep licking in his mouth after eating them. He is a high energy dog so it's possible that these just don't work on him!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] First, thank you to Zesty Paws for the free sample for my dog to try! I will say, he absolutely loves the treats...I don't think he could gobble them up any faster!! As for the calming part, they don't seem to change his overall demeanor, however when he takes his afternoon nap, he is out and nothing disturbs him. I was hoping for a little more relaxed demeanor when he was dealing with our big dog, but these treats did not provide that result.

I was getting a similar item from my vet, saw these and thought I would try them. My dogs love them, I have a 13 year old lab that in his older age has become anxious and a 9 year old hyper terrier mix. I give them to them every morning when we leave to help them stay calm.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] We had just moved our dog from one room to another and he was so anxious in a new environment until I gave him one of these treats and he calmed down and was able to sleep soundly after hours of stressing out! I already bought a bag to refill the container!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I have a rescue dog who is scared of a lot, and giving him these this past week when I had to go into the office or leave for a longer time I would check the cameras and he would be laying on his side on the bed versus curled up on my bed because he got stressed. They also didn't leave him lethargic, as he was still ready to go on our long walks or to play. I will be using these going forward!

We have a fairly new puppy (about 1 month with us) and she gets severe separation anxiety. We had been using L-Theanine drops in her food before we leave, but this is a much simpler option in a yummy peanut-butter-flavored treat form. Our pup loves it and she definitely whines less --we video her while we're gone!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Our dog didn't change at all with these from an energy or anxiousness level. If nothing it felt like he was aggressive or more nervous with us and the kids. He did like the flavor of them and had no issues eating them.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I have two dogs, one is a Boston Terrier, she didn't care for these treats. It might have been the flavor. I do like that they are easy to crumble and mix in her food. My Pitbull enjoyed these treats.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I got this the day before we got a massive storm and gave my Great Dane a couple before it came in really bad and it worked wonders! He's usually really terrified during storms but he slept right through this one no problems!

My dog has anxiety issues and gets stressed very easily so we try to give him a calming supplement every day. I love that these are peanut butter flavored for him as he loves PB and can look forward to these each day. I also love that ingredients like hemp, chamomile, valerian root etc are in the active ingredients - a more natural solution! All in all, a yummy treat for the pup with added benefits!