[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I gave my dog these treats daily and didn't notice any calming effect. He seemed to not really like them or that they get stuck in his mouth because he seemed to need to keep licking in his mouth after eating them. He is a high energy dog so it's possible that these just don't work on him!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] One of my pups like it but the other didn't even touched it. I will say the one that ate it slept all night in a slumber. He usually wakes up around 3am to wee but not when he takes them. He's also a senior and it helps with his little anxiety.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I have two large cane corsos and I tried these treats for them to see if they had a more calming effect on them. I didn't think I saw any change is calming activity, but they did enjoy eating them with no problem. Maybe they need more than the recommended amount but I didn't want to give more for the trial.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] The Gods were smiling upon me when I received this sample (from BzzAgent) in exchange for my honest review. A couple of days after getting this sample in the mail a HUGE storm system swept through my town...lots of thunder, lightening, hail and tornados. I gave these "treats" to my 10lb and my 74lb pups in the hopes that it would calm their sweet nerves during the worst of the storm. These worked like a charm and Leo & Holly were chill and relaxed the entire night! I will say, they both had awful gas from these but we gladly accepted that consequence. I will 100% be keeping these on hand in the pantry from now on!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My dog is a nervous Nelly, I've tried several calming products and none seem to work for him. My issue is he will not eat them. I've tried all the tricks - hide them in his food, wrap them in cheese - he just spits it out. When he does get one down, they seem to take the edge off.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My doggies love these. I have dogs ranging from small to giant and they all get out of control and have separation anxiety. I gave them the recommended dosages and it helped them immensely. I will be buying in the future and have recommended them to my friends and family who have doggies with anxiety or zoomy behaviors.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Upon opening the bag, the smell was ok and not offensive like some treats can be. My dog was very unsure at first and smelled them and walked away. He came back for them, took one and then dropped it. I'm not sure why he was unsure but he did end up eating it. He will eat them now but they are not what he will choose first over other treats. I also do not see calming effects. I have a very high energy GSP with anxiety, I would hope this could work for another breed of dog.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I was asked to try Zesty Paws calming treats in exchange for my honest review. I have a 2 year old corgi who has no stop button and always being a goofball. The only time she slows down is when we have storms. Storms make her shake bark and get physically ill. The dr has given her meds but they do not work and seem to make her more hyper and aware that we are having storms. We had a few days where we had some big storms roll thru and decided this was a great time to try these little bites out. The package recommended 2 bites for her weight. The first day I gave her 1 she it didn't really do anything. The needy day i did the recommended amount and it was a game changer. She had very little anxiety. She didn't bark or shake. She was very calm and didn't even realize it was thundering. The bites let her sleep during the night time storms. By the 3rd day of giving her 2 bites she was very calm. I will say the next day she was groggy for a few hours after getting up, but she was right back to her fluffy googball self after breakfast. I will be using these from now on top help with storms. I'm hopeful they will work just as good come 4th of July as the fireworks are another trigger for her

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I have a very large Labrador, who is TERRIFIED of storms, shakes like a leaf. I received this product the morning of a day when a huuuuge storm was about to hit my city. With my big boy, the bag said 3 calming bites, I gave them to him, and I could tell about 45 minutes later how much calmer he was, I did end up giving him 1 more through the course of the night, which seems to be the right dose for my boy. Needless to say, great product.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I use these treats on my high anxiety 125lb pup and he loves them! He gets so excited for his calming treats he leaves a puddle of drool from the anticipation of me opening the bag! He thoroughly enjoys the taste. He does seem to chill out a bit after eating them