[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My dog loves these. To be fair he loves most treats (lol), but it's nice having these with the added benefit of keeping him calm. He tends to get anxious when we leave the house and while these don't completely solve that, they do seem to take the edge off.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This product is far and away the best of its kind. I had honestly given up on similar products because, in the past, I did not find them to be useful with my two large mixed breed dogs. I received the Calming Plus Bites in exchange for writing a detailed, honest review of the product. And to be honest, I am amazed. My dogs love the treats and they truly do have a calming effect on my pets. I live in a suburban area and there are lots of other dogs in our area, which usually means a lot of barking inside and outside of my house. With these treats, my dogs are no longer responding negatively to the noises around them. These will definitely become a staple of our household shopping list!

I have a rescue pit that has separation anxiety and gets afraid when he hears fireworks. I have tried other zesty paws products and never been disappointed so I gave these a try. He loves the peanut butter flavor and I love the calmness he has after eating them. Two chews and about 30 minutes later he is relaxed without side effects he gets with over the counter methods I have tried. I feel better about giving him something that has natural ingredients. I will be ordering them again.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I had high hopes for these calming bites, but unfortunately, they didn't work for my dogs at all. There was no noticeable calming effect, even after consistent use. On top of that, most of the bites were just small crumbs, which made it hard to give a proper serving. The only reason I'm giving two stars instead of one is because my dogs did seem to like the taste - so at least they work as basic treats. Just don't count on them for any real calming benefits.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My dog was stung by a bee and was very agitated and had high anxiety. I gave my dog the recommended treat and in about 15 minutes she was much calmer, it stopped her anxiety pretty quickly. I definitely would recommend this product for any dog that is anxious or has difficulty being calm.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I received this product for free in exchange for writing the review. These calming Plus Bites actually work and my dog likes them. She thinks these are treats. I admit, I was a bit skeptical on weather they would calm my over the top, jumping dog. I have a hyper 1year old Golden Doodle with an excited personality. The direction says to give her 2 per her weight. I only gave her 1 and within 20 minutes, she was chill as a cucumber. I can't wait to give her these when we go camping this weekend.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Here's the thing, this could be one of those "my dog" things, and not the product itself. We tried them 3 different times. She did not slow her roll, and almost was more anxious. It was strange. I plan to try them again, in a few weeks. She may have just been having an off week. She's typically not super hyper but some weather related noises made her a bit skiddish, and these came in so I figured perfect timing. Using them 3 times I had hoped they'd help her out a bit. Overall mostly the same. With that being said, for another dog these may work just fine and I wouldn't deter someone- in fact I'd want to know if my friends dogs did well with them and if they were chill :) Pros: soft and chewy, not that gross dog treat smell

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I received this product in exchange for an honest review. My dog has some anxiety when traveling and when I am at work. I gave her the recommended amount and she enjoyed and flavor and I saw it calm her down and relaxed while I did some chores around the house. I will continue to use and would repurchase.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I'm not sure these really have any calming affects on my dogs. I do know that they gave my dachshund a very upset stomach. It did not affect my doodles, but they're already pretty calm so maybe that's why. Just so so.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My dog seems to enjoy the taste of these Calming Plus Bites. He gobbles them up quickly. They seem to relax him a bit, but probably not as much as I would like. He's also only 1 year old so I need to consider he's super active with lots of energy. I've been giving them before storms and car rides. Overall they've seemed to help.