I'm just using these when I leave him so I cannot comment a lot on their benefit. I will be better able to judge when we have a storm. He loves them, however, which is a positive

These calming chews work so much better than any other brand I tried. I have a German Shepherd and an Australian Shepherd and they both have anxiety. These chews help relax them and calm them during events, road trips, or social gatherings.

Charlie enjoys the taste of the calming bites, I add half a bite into his dinner. While he does love the product, I'm not sure how effective it is as he is still pretty rambunctious afterwards which is why I gave it 4 stars.

My dog loves the taste of these and gets super excited when i take them out. I also like that it calms him. He has a lot of energy and can be crazy at times, this helps keep him a little more calm than his normal crazy self.

I give my dog the recommended amount of treats in the am and pm and it help tremendously with her separation anxiety and her overall anxiety to environmental surroundings outside!

My dogs loves eating these, he gets very excited when he sees me going in the cabinet for them. The only thing is it takes a lot of them to get him ready for training. I am going to try the advance one next time to see of it works with less "treats"

I've been feeding these with dinner and have definitely noticed my female corgi is more calm and ready for bed in the evenings. She is usually wound up and playing until the minute we go to bed. Its nice to see her relax

So far I've loved giving these to my dog. We are working through separation anxiety and this is what I needed to help take the edge off so we can keep training. It does seem to take a long time to kick in though

We have a very lively lab and these help when we're having friends over for dinner so he's just a little more chill. We recently had a thunderstorm and these helped him nap it out.

Clark's is anxiety is usually so hard to watch, he shakes and pants and is so upset. We have tried everything from the thunder shirt to vet prescribed meds, nothing seems to work as good as these advanced calming treats.