Not awful but not really good either. It took us awhile to find a kibble that soothed the gut of our 5 dogs (as a supplement to homemade food). The Member's Mark salmon recipe was the best one they ever had, after trying even Blue Buffalo and Purina One Instinct. We saw we could get 14 additional pounds by the Big Breed bag for same value, but as soon as we switched to it all the dogs started getting eye boogers and had less solid poops, plus more grass-eating, and awful gas came back. I don't think it's the lowest quality by any means, but there is certainly a quality difference in the Large Breed type vs other Member's Mark types. I'd say other brands were even better than this type. I suspect chicken and fillers are a culprit, given the cheap price offered. I had intentionally not chosen a chicken-based kibble due to the common happening of allergies in the gut even if mild. Clearly all my dogs responded to it simultaneously. If you want good value but still prioritize your pup's health, just go with the Salmon, Lamb, or Beef. It's worth the difference. Idk about the chicken one, but again chicken-base generally isn't the healthiest choice for our furry friends.

We exclusively fed Blue Buffalo when I came across this food about a month ago. We have two Great Pyrenees and a medium sized hound. When offered both options, they all go for the Sam's Club food. Considering the difference in price we will use this as our main dog food, supplementing for one of the dogs.

So far my golden retriever half heeler did like it. We transitioned maybe twice and he does take transitions very well. He did not have any problems or issues with this brand of kibble. He does prefer tiny kibble but I mean he eats everything, slowly but surely. I am about to transition my full golden retriever puppy, I got the okay from the vet!

My husky just loves this food. I'm impressed with the ingredients compared to a "name" brand, we were feeding her. The "name" brand was full of garbage and made her poop constantly. We may try the other flavors that Member's Mark brand has. Their ingredients look good too.

I used to be a hills science diet fan, but i was tired of the increasing price. Did a lot of research and came to find out that hills was sneaking in ingredients i didn't agree with. Lesson learned, READ THE INGREDIENTS. Did a side by side comparison and this dog food was much better quality and over HALF the cost! SOLD. Sams, dont ever stop making this dog food!!!

Pet devours food without hesitation.

My dogs favorite food. And it’s a great price here!

Both dogs seem to have better digestion on this food

Dogs love it, almost same as wholesome brand. Good ingredients but saving a couple bucks.

Our dog really likes this.