my cats really like this food. they turn their nose up to all kinds of different cat food so it's hard to find anything they like. but the problem i found that half the food was crumbled it's small bits anyways and to have that muchb of crumble i find wasteful of money in not sure why it is so crumbly but i won't buy again because i felt the value for the money wasn't there considering all the crumbled unusable product.

My cats love this food and the ingredients are better than many. Sadly Sam's has decided to discontinue this brand leaving us with only a few options that are not that great. I am now rushing to find something to replaces while I still have enough to try to transfer them to a new products without causing stress more than necessary to their digestive systems. If you love this product don't hesitate to tell corporate! Maybe they will choose to keep!

i was excited for my cat to try this. Looked good with ingredients, price, etc. Only problem is she wouldn't touch it! i tried giving some to neighbors in my apartment building who have cats. only one cat out of 6 would eat it. I ended up returning it. i can't believe those incentivized reviews. Two dogs ran into a neighbor's apartment who had cats. The dogs gobbled up the cat's food but wouldn't touch the Member's Mark cat food that I had given her to try!

I adopted 6 feral cats and needed to get on a feeding program. They all come running, and the bowls are emptied within minutes. my only complaint is it's discontinued. However, all Makers Mark dog food if plentiful. With all these great reviews, why would you discontinue. I would like to keep buying this but can not locate this food anywhere. It is sad that Sam's isn’t making this cat food available anymore. But still on the site.

Our cats love this food but we are on our last bag. We can’t find it in any warehouse anymore. They’ve been eliminated from stock. And the app will not let us purchase any for shipping. It says it’s available for shipping but when we go to check out, it says unavailable. Our cats don’t want any other food so this is very disappointing that other people are able to purchase this food but we cannot in southern California

My cats love it and looking at the ingredients it seems high quality. Only problem I have is finding it. My store stopped carrying it and I need to check back daily to see if it's available online. Best to order ahead because when you run out they probably won't have it in stock.

We have not tried this yet.

my cats love it but now I can't get it in the stores but only online and had to pay $10 more

thought I'd try this cat food, neither of my cats would touch it. They have never been picky before, going to switch to something else I guess.

my cats eat everything... except this food. not sure what about this they dont like but neither of my 2 cats are eating this.