I opted to switch to this dry food because the recipe is more nutritious than similarly priced alternatives. It's always a risk changing food, but I am glad I took a risk on this one. So far theres been no issues with transition. For context my family owns 5 cats and each one ate the food. Firstly, the flavour. This is the first dry cat food where our cats actively tried to open the food container to eat more. Needles to say, I believe they like the taste. Size and texture, think BB pellet size as opposed to kibble size. Again, our cats had no issues with the change in shape. I did have to adjust the amount I feed since the overall volume per cup is different (I weigh the food beforehand). Thirdly, the smell of the cat food I did not find obnoxious in any way, maybe your typical dry cat food smell. Although it does not linger in the air. I decant the food into a container. However, I can see how a resealable bag would be useful to some owners. it's a nice touch that could otherwise be useful. Overall, I would recommend this, and as long as Sams Club continues to sell it. It will be the cat food of choice for my cats.

Since I feed my dog MM limited ingredient dog food and swear by it I had mentioned numerous times that I wished there was a MM cat kibble and lo and behold there is now. Read the ingredient and guaranteed analysis and as expected it checks all the boxes for me and the cats love it also....Hopefully it sellls alot so they will keep making it...🙂

I looked at the ingredients and compared it to Blue Buff... as they are strikingly similar. My cats are consuming this without hesitation and now is my go to dry food. I was concerned about it being a one time trial because it disappeared quickly but now see that it is a stable stocking.

None of my cats would touch it. Smelled it and walked away. I smellwd it.. smells like POOP, COW POOP, HORSE POOP, DOG POOP... BUT CLEARLY POOP! I returbed it and had the cust service gal smell it and she TOTALLY agreed! I discussed w her to bring forward to management because i feel it was contaminated and needed to be investigated for recall.

My cats all LOVE this food and will beg for it every meal much more adamantly than with other food we have bought. The ingredients on this food are good and the first three ingredients are meat, which us important to me. I would definitely recommend this to others!

At first the price and the nutritional table looked very promising, but the reality is that the final decision is made by the cats, they didn't even eat it mixed with their previous food... we had to return it. Maybe should offer a sample to avoid returning such a large package.

It caused two out of three cats to have an allergic reaction. A cat allergic to a new food could potentially experience nasal congestion, among other symptoms. Food allergies in cats can manifest in various ways, including respiratory issues like sneezing and nasal discharge, as well as skin and gastrointestinal problems. 

Purchased one week ago. Mixed some with existing cat food to introduce into cats diet. Two cats absolutely refused to eat MM Prime Feast with Chicken Salmon Dry Cat Food. They picked out existing Cat Food and left the MM Prime Feast with Chicken Salmon Dry Cat Food. We had placed this in storage container and threw out the bag it came in. Will make a trip to town to purchase what they will eat. Will try giving MM to local shelter.

I’ve tried quite a few dry foods for my cats, and Member’s Mark has honestly been one of the best affordable options I’ve found. All of my cats love it and eat it without hesitation. What really stood out to me is that the ingredient list is much better than many other budget brands that rely heavily on corn and meat by-products. It’s nice to find a kibble at this price point that focuses more on quality ingredients instead of fillers. For anyone trying to feed multiple cats while still paying attention to nutrition, this has been a great option. If your cat doesn’t seem interested at first, it may just be because they’re used to stronger-smelling foods like Cat Chow or other highly processed brands. Sometimes higher-quality foods can seem less appealing initially. Mixing it in gradually with their current food and giving them a little time to adjust can make a big difference. Overall, this is a great, affordable option if you’re looking for a better-quality kibble without the high price tag.

Transitioned my cats like it said. Seemed fine at first until one stared to throw up and refused to eat. Ended up taking her to the vet with an IV to get fluids. $600 later she feels better and eats wet food. Still refuses to eat this food. Had another cat throw up blood. Instantly switched out the food and they started eating again. Not sure if they had an allergic reaction or what.