My dog was too picky for this because it’s like a human cookie. Its ingredients are just peanut butter and banana and oat. My dog wasn’t attracted to that and it smells and feels like a toddler cookie. The texture is nice, the cookie is nice. I tried it and found it was good. They give you so many and it’s well worth the price. Wish my dog would eat them but I thought they were good.

I have 2 small dogs and they both love these treats. I have given them things with peanut butter before which they love but the addition of banana makes them even better. These will last a long time because they are large enough to give them smaller pieces.

These treat are a hit with my 2 dogs they love them I wish the bag had more treats and less air the bag is over 50% air and 50% products it makes it look like your getting more than you actually get. So they don’t last very long that why my star rating is lower

The two dogs really enjoyed these treats and even started smelling the package before we even opened it. Peanut butter is how we get them in the bath so it’s literally their favorite treat. Both doggies were doing tricks and posing for pictures to get another treat. My smaller dog did bite it my big girl just ate it even too quick for me to record. We have been using and nothing seems like it’s a problem we have never had this brand before but we might be switching if they continue to love working for these treats

My dogs love these. They love to sniff the bag out. They are just the right size that my dogs can take smaller bites and it doesn't hurt their teeth. The peanut butter appeals to my dogs. The banana made them hesitant but then when they tried them they loved it.

These Member's Mark Peanut Butter and Banana flavored Dog Treats were absolutely loved by my two dogs. Even though the treats are a larger in size and my dogs are small (15lbs) they were able to eat these treats with no problem. The treats are soft and chewy as the name indicates and make it easy for the dog to enjoy.

These dog treats look like little cookies. They are firm enough not to fall apart, but not too hard for discriminating chewers. The ingredient list looks like any store bought cookie would. There is no noticeable smell like some dog treats have. Both of my dogs eat them up and come back for more.

My doggies FAVORITE treat!! This is now the only treat she will eat since I started giving them to her. They are very soft and chewy, easy to digest and they are her favorite flavors!! Peanut butter and banana! Big plus is that the smell of the treats aren’t overpowering!!!

The grand-pups loved these treats! They were drooling after the first bite, begging for more! The treats have all simple, natural ingredients in a very big bag! The individual treats are big in size as well, you can break them in half for small to medium size dogs. In the picture i placed a lime next to the treat to show the size.

I have a 12 year old black lab and recently acquired a 8 week old black lab puppy. I thought I would use these treats as incentives during my training routines. This worked like a charm. Both dogs loved them and were very attentive during training. I especially like how they held togeter in by pouch.