My Greyt likes them but makes huge mess eating them. Not soft …. Border line crunchy. Crumbs go everywhere.

I really wanted to love these because of the price and clean ingredients. These were the only new thing I gave my golden and they made her sick. Her stomach got very upset, she vomited and had diarrhea. Just use caution!

My dogs won't touch these. The bag says human grade so I tried them and I understand why. There is no banana or peanut butter flavor, they taste like protein powder and that's it..... HORRIBLE!!

These are my favorite dog treats because I can leave them whole or easily break them apart for weight control and training. They have stayed soft in the treat jar. My 3 labs gobble them up.

Our two dogs wouldn't eat them. I gave one to each of our dogs. They dropped them in the middle of the floor and walked over them for two days before I finally picked them up and threw them out. (The treats, not the dogs)

I purchased these soft chews on September 16th and when I opened the bag they were covered in a white mold. Be careful it was hard to see but it smelled really sour. Sam's club refunded me right away! Thank you Sam's club customer service!

Always hungry black lab loves these...can't give her too many but there's no hesitation when I offer them up....she gobbles em right down and waits for another.

Smell good, they are soft but firm so good for young and old. Large sized bag for a great price! Already ordered 2 more in case Sam's stops carrying them!

Dohgs loves these, and they're a "decently" healthy treat.

Max just loves these snacks! As soon as he hears me rattle the package he comes running