Found mold on multiple pieces in the original bag the second time I opened them.

They don't smell good and neither of my two dogs will eat them.

my dog seemed to like them well enough, but I just can't get over the fact that they smell like wet paint. I have not noticed mold on any of mine (yet), but am keeping a watch for it as per some other reviews have mentioned. most likely won't be purchasing again.

made my dog sick. Was the only new thing he ate. Tried 3 different days and made him vomit. So ne careful, keep an eye on your doggy.

None of my 3 dogs seem to like these. They have loved other Member's Mark dog treats in the past, but they really don't like this particular flavor.

Soft but they don't break apart in the bag like other soft treats we have tried. Both of our large breed dogs love them.

Absolutely love these! They're soft and if they taste like they smell, its no wonder why our dogs go crazy for them! I also like that its a big bag so we don't have to buy multiple bags at a time. As soon as we open the bag they come running!

When I received the dog treats my dog loved them. Unfortunately as we got further into the package I noticed there were wet. I couldn’t quite figure out why. So I ended up throwing them away. My did did love them though.

I’m not really giving it a bad review because I know how of a picky eater my chihuahua is. I tried several times ti see if he would eat it but no luck. I’m sure others dogs would like them. But they look fresh and smell delicious

Our dog loved these and couldnt get enough. She gobbled them up anytime we gave her some. They have a faint banana smell and were a little on the soft side like a nice cookie. Really good and easy to eat for our older dog.